Medieval rhetoric and poetic to 1400 : $b Interpreted from representative worksBaldwin, Charles Sears
History
Medieval rhetoric and poetic to 1400 : $b Interpreted from representative works
Baldwin, Charles Sears
Literature, Medieval -- History and criticism; Poetics -- History -- To 1500; Rhetoric, Medieval
The sophistic marking of balance by rime (_homœoteleuton_), easy in Greek
or Latin through the recurrence of inflectional endings, is so forced
in English as to be very rare and in very bad taste. Word-play, on the
other hand, has always been one of the commonest devices for enhancing
balance into epigram. “Figures do not lie. The trouble with statistics
is not that figures lie, but that liars figure.” Paronomasia is not
sophistic; but, like other jingles, it attracted the sophists too much,
as to-day it attracts Mr. Chesterton and Mr. Bernard Shaw.
(4) _Clausula_
Balance is only one mode of rhythm. The sophists were so preoccupied
with it as often to risk monotony. For though they boasted of variety,
they were too fond of certain rhythms, and too anxious to mark them,
to achieve much flexibility. Their idea of aptness as conformity to an
assumed character or occasion led them rather to cast a whole passage in
one stylistic pattern.
Next to the perfecting of balances, they studied most attentively
sentence cadences.[80] Of _clausulæ_, as of other effects of style,
they had a classified store for selection. Though we find it hard to
follow them here, and impossible to translate their _clausulæ_ in terms
of English stress rhythms, we are not warranted in dismissing their
studies of rhythm as idle. True, they often overdid rhythm as they
overdid technic in general; but English prose has rarely been in danger
of this excess, and in particular it has been surest with those who have
controlled cadence. Sentence emphasis is the clue to mastery of sentence
movement. Its greater masters, modern as well as ancient, have grasped
this not only as logic, but as cadence. The flaw in sophistic rhythms
is their emptiness, the pursuit of them for themselves. The difference
between the sounding _clausula_ of dilation and the solving _clausula_
of mounting emotion can be heard in the same English sophist. All the
following sentences conclude well for the ear; but whereas the first two
are prolonged by decorative additions, the last is an ascending period.
The boy rose to a splendour and a noonday prosperity, both
personal and public, that rang through the records of his
people, and became a by-word amongst his posterity for a
thousand years, until the sceptre was departing from Judah.
_Joan of Arc_, 1.
How if it should be some Marie Antoinette, the widowed queen,
coming forward on the scaffold, and presenting to the morning
air her head, turned grey by sorrow, daughter of Cæsars
kneeling down humbly to kiss the guillotine, as one that
worships death? _Ibid._, 26.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account