Mendel's principles of heredity: A defenceMendel, Gregor
Science
Mendel's principles of heredity: A defence
Mendel, Gregor
Heredity; Hybridization; Mendel's law; Weldon, Walter Frank Raphael. Mendel's laws of alternative inheritance in peas
As an objection to the deduction of purity of germ-cells, however, it
is to be noted that though true intermediates did not generally occur,
yet the intensity in which the characters appeared did vary in degree,
and it is not easy to see how the hypothesis of _perfect_ purity in the
reproductive cells can be supported in such cases. Be this, however, as
it may, there is no doubt we are beginning to get new lights of a most
valuable kind on the nature of heredity and the laws which it obeys. It
is to be hoped that these indications will be at once followed up by
independent workers. Enough has been said to show how necessary it is
that the subjects of experiment should be chosen in such a way as to
bring the laws of heredity to a real test. For this purpose the first
essential is that the differentiating characters should be few, and
that all avoidable complications should be got rid of. Each experiment
should be reduced to its simplest possible limits. The results obtained
by Galton, and also the new ones especially described in this paper,
have each been reached by restricting the range of observation to one
character or group of characters, and it is certain that by similar
treatment our knowledge of heredity may be rapidly extended.
* * * * *
To the above popular presentation of the essential facts, made for
an audience not strictly scientific, some addition, however brief,
is called for. First, in regard to the law of Ancestry, spoken of on
p. 5. Those who are acquainted with Pearson’s _Grammar of Science_,
2nd ed. published early in 1900, the same author’s paper in _Proc.
R. S._ vol. 66, 1900, p. 140, or the extensive memoir (pubd. Oct.
1900), on the inheritance of coat-colour in horses and eye-colour in
man (_Phil. Trans._ 195, A, 1900, p. 79), will not need to be told that
the few words I have given above constitute a most imperfect diagram of
the operations of that law as now developed. Until the appearance of
these treatises it was, I believe, generally considered that the law
of Ancestral Heredity was to be taken as applying to phenomena like
these (coat-colour, eye-colour, &c.) where the inheritance is generally
_alternative_, as well as to the phenomena of _blended_ inheritance.
Pearson, in the writings referred to, besides withdrawing other large
categories of phenomena from the scope of its operations, points out
that the law of Ancestral Heredity does not satisfactorily express the
cases of alternative inheritance. He urges, and with reason, that these
classes of phenomena should be separately dealt with.
* * * * *
The whole issue as regards the various possibilities of heredity now
recognized will be made clearer by a very brief exposition of the
several conceptions involved.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account