Mental diseases: a public health problemMay, James Vance
Science
Mental diseases: a public health problem
May, James Vance
Mental health services; Psychology, Pathological
syphilitic psychoses, twenty per cent manic-depressive insanity,
fourteen per cent dementia praecox, and seven per cent epilepsy.
Statistics at that time were not available on purely psychopathic
conditions, owing to the classification used.
In discussing the etiology of shell shock Col. Salmon divides those
conditions into four groups—1. Cases in which death is caused by
exploding shells or mines without external signs of injury; 2. Those
in which severe neurological symptoms follow burial or concussion by
explosions, with characteristic syndromes suggesting the operation
of mechanical factors; 3. Cases in which there may or may not be
damage to the central nervous system, but showing neuroses similar
to those of civil life—"In this group of cases, in which there is
possibility but no proof of damage to the central nervous system, the
symptoms present which might be attributable to such damage are quite
overshadowed by those characteristic of the neuroses;" and 4. Cases in
which even the slightest damage to the central nervous system from the
direct effect of explosions is exceedingly improbable. He also found
that hundreds of men who have not been exposed to battle conditions
at all develop symptoms almost identical with those described as
"shell shock," many occurring in the non-expeditionary forces. The
psychogenic factors involved are very well summarized by Col. Salmon
in the following words:—"The psychological basis of the war neuroses
(like that of the neuroses in civil life) is an elaboration, with
endless variations, of one central theme: escape from an intolerable
situation in real life to one made tolerable by the neurosis. The
conditions which may make intolerable the situation in which a soldier
finds himself hardly need stating. Not only fear, which exists at some
time in nearly all soldiers and in many is constantly present, but
horror, revulsion against the ghastly duties which must be sometimes
performed, intense longing for home, particularly in married men,
emotional situations resulting from the interplay of personal conflicts
and military conditions, all play their part in making an escape of
some sort mandatory. Death provides a means which cannot be sought
consciously. Flight or desertion is rendered impossible by ideals of
duty, patriotism and honor, by the reactions acquired by training or
imposed by discipline and by herd reactions. Malingering is a military
crime and is not at the disposal of those governed by higher ethical
conceptions. Nevertheless, the conflict between a simple and direct
expression in flight of the instinct of self-preservation and such
factors demands some sort of compromise. Wounds solve the problem most
happily for many men and the mild exhilaration so often seen among
the wounded has a sound psychological basis. Others with a sufficient
adaptability find a means of adjustment. The neurosis provides a means
of escape so convenient that the real source of wonder is not that it
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account