Perhaps even this great master of narrative lacks variety--as who does
not? His method, whatever the topic, is ever the same. His sentences,
his paragraphs, his chapters are pitched one and all in the same key.
It is a very fine and moving key. Many an elevated strain and rich
harmony commend it alike to the ear and to the imagination. It is
employed with an easy mastery, and is made to serve to admiration a
wide range of themes. But it is always the same key, and some themes it
will not serve. An infinite variety plays through all history. Every
scene has its own air and singularity. Incidents cannot all be rightly
set in the narrative if all be set alike. As the scene shifts, the tone
of the narrative must change: the narrator’s choice of incident and his
choice of words; the speed and method of his sentence; his own thought,
even, and point of view. Surely his battle pages must resound with the
tramp of armies and the fearful din and rush of war. In peace he must
catch by turns the hum of industry, the bustle of the street, the calm
of the country-side, the tone of parliamentary debate, the fancy, the
ardor, the argument of poets and seers and quiet students. Snatches of
song run along with sober purpose and strenuous endeavor through every
nation’s story. Coarse men and refined, mobs and ordered assemblies,
science and mad impulse, storm and calm, are all alike ingredients of
the various life. It is not all epic. There is rough comedy and brutal
violence. The drama can scarce be given any strict, unbroken harmony
of incident, any close logical sequence of act or nice unity of scene.
To pitch it all in one key, therefore, is to mistake the significance
of the infinite play of varied circumstance that makes up the yearly
movement of a people’s life.
It would be less than just to say that Green’s pages do not reveal
the variety of English life the centuries through. It is his glory,
indeed, as all the world knows, to have broadened and diversified the
whole scale of English history. Nowhere else within the compass of
a single book can one find so many sides of the great English story
displayed with so deep and just an appreciation of them all, or of the
part of each in making up the whole. Green is the one man among English
historians who has restored the great fabric of the nation’s history
where its architecture was obscure, and its details were likely to be
lost or forgotten. Once more, because of him, the vast Gothic structure
stands complete, its majesty and firm grace enhanced at every point by
the fine tracery of its restored details.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account