Poets, Spanish; Spanish poetry -- History and criticism; Spanish poetry -- Translations into English
It is much to be regretted that Zorrilla has in all his works allowed
carelessnesses to prevail, which too often mar the effect of his
verses, and still more that he has often inserted some that were of
very inferior merit compared with the rest. It is not to be supposed
that an author can be equally sustained in all his productions, but it
is somewhat extraordinary in his volumes to find some poems of such
transcendent merit, and others so inferior. These, however, are very
few, and probably were hastily composed and hastily published, to
supply the demand arising for the day. He is probably the only author
in Spain who has profited by the sale of his writings to any extent,
and to do this he must have been often under the necessity of tasking
his mind severely, without regard to its spontaneous suggestions. Thus
then, when he found his inspiration failing, he has often had recourse
to memory, and repeated from himself, and even from others, verses
previously published. It is to be hoped that he may be induced soon to
give the world a revised edition of his works, in which the oversights
may be corrected, and the poems unworthy of his fame may be omitted.
On reading over dispassionately the ‘Lines to Larra,’ by which he
was first brought so prominently into notice, it may occasion some
surprise to learn they had produced so remarkable an effect. If they
had previously been read over alone to any one of the auditors, he
probably might not have considered them so ideal, so beautiful, or so
original as they seemed at the public recital. Some phrase might have
appeared incomprehensible, some sentiment exaggerated or not true; some
expression or line, hard or weak or forced. He might have observed a
want of order or connection in the ideas, or the whole to be vague
and leaving no fixed thought in the mind; or he might have pronounced
them, as they have been since pronounced, an imitation of Victor Hugo
or Lamartine. But to the auditors assembled, in the excited state of
their feelings, there was no time for reflection or criticism. It was
a composition of the hour for that particular scene,--for themselves,
in language and feelings with which they could sympathize. Thus the
verses seized on their minds and electrified them, so that they had no
time to dwell on any discussion or dispute of their merits, but yielded
at once to the fascination of the melodious verse they heard, and the
appropriate application of the homage they testified.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account