Nietzsche and ArtLudovici, Anthony M. (Anthony Mario)
Philosophy
Nietzsche and Art
Ludovici, Anthony M. (Anthony Mario)
Aesthetics, German -- 19th century; Nietzsche, Friedrich Wilhelm, 1844-1900 -- Aesthetics
But of all modern musical critics, perhaps Richard Hamann is
the most desperate concerning the work of recent composers. His book on
Impressionism and Art entirely supports Nietzsche's condemnation of the
drift of modern music, and in his references to Wagner, even the words
lie uses seem to have been drawn from the Nietzschean vocabulary.[36]
Briefly what he complains of in the music of the day is its want of
form,[37] its abuse of discord,[38] its hundred and one different artifices
for producing nerve-exciting and nerve-stimulating effects,[39] its
predilection in favour of cacophonous instruments,[40] its unwarrantable
sudden changes in rhythm or tempo within the same movement,[41] its habit
of delaying the solving chord, as in the love-death passage of Tristan
and Isolde,[42] and, finally, its realism, of which a typical example is
Strauss's "By a Lonely Brook"--all purely Nietzschean objections!
Well might Mr. Allen cry out: "Oh for the classic simplicity of a
bygone age, the golden age of music that hath passed away!"[43] But
the trouble does not end here; for, if we are to believe a certain
organ-builder, bell-founder and pianoforte-maker of ripe experience, it
has actually descended into the sphere of instrument-making as well.[44]
[12] Okakura-Kakuzo, _The Book of Tea_, pp. 112, 113.
[13] _The Book of Tea_, p. 112.
[14] See in this regard _B. T._, pp. 54, 55.
[15] _Z._, II. XLVI.
[16] _G. E._, p.121.
[17] _W. P._, Vol. I, p. 55.
[18] _D. D._, Aph. 169.
[19] This is such a common fault that it is superfluous to give
particular examples of it, but the New War Office in Whitehall is a
good case in point.
[20] Local Government Board building; Piccadilly Hotel (Regent St.
side).
[21] Piccadilly Hotel (Piccadilly side), and the Sicilian Avenue,
Bloomsbury.
[22] New Scotland Yard.
[23] Gaiety Theatre; the new Y.M.C.A. building, Tottenham Court Road.
[24] Local Government Board.
[25] Gaiety Theatre.
[26] Marylebone Workhouse.
[27] See Fergusson's Introduction to his _History of Modern
Architecture_.
[28] See W. Morris's _Address on the Decorative Arts_, pp. 18, 19.
[29] _Trois crises de l'art actuel_, p. 243.
[30] _The Student's Musical History_, p. 1.
[31] _History of Music_, Vol. II, p. 927. See also _The Student's
Musical History_, by Henry Davey, p. 97. "Weakness of rhythm is the
main reason of the inferiority of the romantic composers to their
predecessors."
[32] _History of Music_, p. 1195. See also P. v. Lind, _Moderner
Geschmack und moderne Musik_, in which the author complains of the
excessive virtuosity, want of faith and science of modern music, while
on p. 34 he, too, calls all modern musicians romanticists.
[33] See especially _C. W._, pp. 59, 60.
[34] _W. P._, Vol. II, p. 276.
[35] _Moderner Geschmack und moderne Musik_, p. 54.
[36] Der Impressionismus in Leben und Kunst.
[37] _Ibid_., pp. 53, 57.
[38] _Ibid_., p. 64.
[39] _Ibid_., p. 67.
[40] _Ibid_., p. 69.
[41] _Ibid_., p. 74.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account