Notes on Novelists, with Some Other NotesJames, Henry
History
Notes on Novelists, with Some Other Notes
James, Henry
Fiction -- History and criticism; Novelists
I may mention at all events the slightly perverse fact that, thanks, on
this side, to the highest watermark of translation, Signor D’Annunzio
makes his best appeal to the English public as a dramatist. Of each of
the three English versions of other examples of his work whose titles
are inscribed at the beginning of these remarks it may be said that they
are adequate and respectable considering the great difficulty
encountered. The author’s highest good fortune has nevertheless been at
the hands of his French interpreter, who has managed to keep constantly
close to him—allowing for an occasional inconsequent failure of courage
when the directness of the original _brave l’honnêteté_—and yet to
achieve a tone not less idiomatic, and above all not less marked by
“authority,” than his own. Mr. Arthur Symons, among ourselves, however,
has rendered the somewhat insistent eloquence of “La Gioconda” and the
intricate and difficult verse of “Francesca” with all due sympathy, and
in the latter case especially—a highly arduous task—with remarkably
patient skill. It is not his fault, doubtless, if the feet of his
English text strike us as moving with less freedom than those of his
original; such being the hard price paid always by the translator who
tries for correspondence from step to step, tries for an identical
order. Even less is he responsible for its coming still more home to us
in a translation that the meagre anecdote here furnishing the subject,
and on which the large superstructure rests, does not really lend itself
to those developments that make a full or an interesting tragic
complexity. Behind the glamour of its immense literary association the
subject of “Francesca” is for purposes of essential, of enlarged
exhibition delusive and “short.”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account