On the other hand, both in Great Britain and in the United States
the sufferings which the COs endured in World War I when there was
virtually no legal or social recognition of them, were, according to all
competent observers, largely responsible for the fact that fairly liberal
provisions for COs were made in World War II. The Army did not want to
“be bothered with these fellows again.”
Two Miles or None
This does not, of course, mean that if the imposition of alternative
service is accepted, it should be rendered grudgingly or that feelings
of hostility toward government officials with whom one may deal are
appropriate. Quite the contrary. If we decide to go with Caesar one mile,
the Gospel enjoins us to go two! We have the choice of not going along at
all or going two miles, but not a skimpy one mile.
I think it is now generally admitted that there was not a great deal of
this glad, spontaneous “second miling” on the part of the conscript COs
in World War II, though there was considerable talk about it among older
folks. Civilian Public Service in large measure simply did not operate on
the high spiritual plane that was originally hoped and is still sometimes
implied or stated, but was for many making the best of a bad business,
perhaps for lack of clear leading or the courage to follow another course.
It will be recalled that there were a considerable number of Civilian
Public Service men who declared flatly that it was inconsistent, and
indeed hypocritical, to talk of spontaneous service under conscription.
“We are here,” they said, “not because our desire to serve brought us
here. We are here because the government as part of its war program
passed a conscription law and under that law took us by the scruff of the
neck and is forcing us to do this job. We have no choice but this or the
army or jail. That fact is bound to color this whole experience, except
perhaps for those who can shut their eyes to reality. Any one who denies
this is a hypocrite.”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account