Meunier rises to the height of the Vedic hymns when he turns towards
the countryman and his heroic deeds in nourishing mankind. In the
relief, “The Harvest,” a band of reapers—four men and two women—are
grappling with the ripe corn. One seizes violently the stalks, the
second, bending forward, makes a wide stroke with his sickle, a woman
binds into sheaves the ears that have been mown. In the background, one
longing for rest looks at the position of the sun, and another, _rapido
fessus aestu_ (fatigued by the scorching summer heat), to use Vergil’s
words, wipes the sweat from his brow. There is the note of the Eclogues
about this work. Over it floats the consecration of the lofty act with
which the rooted son of the soil, the ploughman—the creator and bearer
of all civilisation—gains the bread of mankind out of the earth. A
single figure, “June,” is also created from this emotion. It is the
realisation in free sculpture of a _motif_ from the relief. A reaper,
stripped to the waist, emaciated by the heavy toil of harvesting,
exhausted by his day’s work, leans upon his scythe and glances, shading
his eyes with his hand, at the sun—“I would it were bedtime and all was
over.” One would like to press the hand of this brave, good fellow,
or at any rate that of the artist who has represented him to us so
faithfully and straightforwardly.
All Meunier’s works have not this delicacy; many are weak, some
absolute failures. As an instance of such I point to “The Puddlers,”
though it has been particularly admired by some critics. Three
iron-founders stand at the open stoke-hole of the puddle-furnace, and
feed it with mighty pieces for melting. From the opening issue steam
and smoke, which curl round the three men wielding rakes and tongs, and
eddy upwards. Meunier has tried to represent this steam in sculpture.
He has given it a concrete form, necessarily the same corporeality as
the bodies, tools, blocks of metal, the flaming furnace; for sculpture
possesses no means of differentiating the thickness of matter, when
it abandons the mere engraved line or the make-shift of various
perforations. The result is, that instead of smoke there is an amazing
image which partly reminds us of an untrimmed dab of plaster, partly
of a weather-beaten stalactite. Meunier was originally a painter, and
took to sculpture only late in life. His “Puddlers” are formed with
the technique of a painter, from which the artist did not immediately
emancipate himself. Another relief, “The Bricklayers,” is absolutely
a mistake. Two men are standing in the loam-pit and handing up the
bricks to their mates above. They do this with theatrical gestures,
as if a conquered king were handing over his crown to his conqueror.
The contrast between the bombastic movement and its vulgar purpose is
so grotesque that the picture has an irresistibly comic effect. Here
Meunier is, for the only occasion in all the works of his with which I
am acquainted, insincere and affected.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account