Outlines of a Critical Theory of EthicsDewey, John
Philosophy
Outlines of a Critical Theory of Ethics
Dewey, John
Ethics
Kant's position on this point seems impregnable. "It is
surprising," he says, "that men otherwise astute can
think it possible to distinguish between higher and lower
desires, according as the ideas which are connected with
the feeling of pleasure have their origin in the senses
or in the understanding; for when we inquire what are the
determining grounds of desire, and place them in some
expected pleasantness, it is of no consequence whence
the _idea_ of this pleasing object is derived, but only
how much it _pleases_.... The only thing that concerns
one, in order to decide choice, is how great, how long
continued, how easily obtained and how often repeated,
this agreeableness is. For as to the man who wants money
to spend, it is all the same whether the gold was dug out
of the mountain or washed out of the sand, provided it is
every-where accepted at the same value; so the man who
cares only for the enjoyment of life does not ask whether
the ideas are of the understanding or the senses, but only
_how much_ and _how great pleasure_ they will give for the
longest time."
See also Bradley, Op. cit., pp. 105-110.
When we ask how the differences in quality are established and how
we translate this qualitative difference into moral difference, the
surrender of pleasure as the standard becomes even more evident.
We must know not only the fact of different qualities, but how to
decide which is 'higher' than any other. We must bring the qualities
before a tribunal of judgment which applies to them some standard of
measurement. In themselves qualities may be different, but they are not
higher and lower. What is the tribunal and what is the law of judgment?
According to Mill the tribunal is the preference of those who are
acquainted with both kinds of pleasure.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account