Pages from a Journal with Other PapersWhite, William Hale
General
Pages from a Journal with Other Papers
White, William Hale
English essays
Superstition is a matter of _relative_ evidence. A thousand years ago it
was not so easy as it is now to obtain rigid demonstration in any
department except mathematics. Much that was necessarily the basis of
action was as incapable of proof as the story of St. George and the
Dragon, and consequently it is hardly fair to say that the dark ages were
more superstitious than our own. Nor does every belief, even in
supernatural objects, deserve the name of superstition. Suppose that the
light which struck down St. Paul on his journey to Damascus was due to
his own imagination, the belief that it came from Jesus enthroned in the
heavens was a sign of strength and not of weakness. Beliefs of this
kind, in so far as they exalt man, prove greatness and generosity, and
may be truer than the scepticism which is formally justified in rejecting
them. If Christ never rose from the dead, the women who waited at the
sepulchre were nearer to reality than the Sadducees, who denied the
resurrection.
There is a half-belief, which we find in Virgil that is not superstition,
nor inconstancy, nor cowardice. A child-like faith in the old creed is
no longer possible, but it is equally impossible to surrender it. I
refer now not to those who select from it what they think to be in
accordance with their reason, and throw overboard the remainder with no
remorse, but rather to those who cannot endure to touch with sacrilegious
hands the ancient histories and doctrines which have been the
depositaries of so much that is eternal, and who dread lest with the
destruction of a story something precious should also be destroyed. The
so-called superstitious ages were not merely transitionary. Our regret
that they have departed is to be explained not by a mere idealisation of
the past, but by a conviction that truths have been lost, or at least
have been submerged. Perhaps some day they may be recovered, and in some
other form may again become our religion.
JUDAS ISCARIOT—WHAT CAN BE SAID FOR HIM?
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account