Physical science in the time of Nero : $b being a translation of the Quaestiones naturales of SenecaSeneca, Lucius Annaeus
Philosophy
Physical science in the time of Nero : $b being a translation of the Quaestiones naturales of Seneca
Seneca, Lucius Annaeus
Comets; Earthquakes; Meteorology -- Early works to 1800
One or two considerations derived from the present arrangement will
serve to throw light upon this point. In the first place, Book IV., as
we have it, is evidently composite. Between Chaps. II. and III. there
is a deep hiatus. In the former chapter the discussion of the Nile is
cut short, and the author’s own view is not even indicated, much less
established; while the latter opens so abruptly as at least to suggest
that it may have originally been preceded by something with which it
stood in organic sequence.
Again, the several Books do not conform to the author’s division of the
subject as set forth in the opening of Book II. (51), but follow--or
precede--one another anyhow.
Then, three of the Books (I. III. IV.) have a formal Preface, while the
others have not, though in them, too, with the exception of the Sixth,
the opening chapter is introductory in character.
Any attempt to restore a more intelligible order must depend for its
success on the extent to which we may assume Seneca to have been a
methodiser. In Book II. i, he certainly states very distinctly the
divisions of his subject--(_a_) things in the heavens, (_b_) things
between heaven and earth, (_c_) things on the earth. But it by no
means follows that he himself maintained this order of treatment, or
that he always exhausted one subject before passing on to the next.
The division evidently enumerates the subjects in order of dignity or
worth, and may have little, if any, relation to the order of their
discussion; in fact, in Book II. he goes on immediately to deal with
meteorology, his second and not his first topic.
Bernhardt (_Die Anschauung des Seneca vom Universum_, p. 7) frankly
accepts the traditional order of the Books, and finds its explanation
in the distinction between phenomena and elements. The first three
Books deal with the phenomena of heaven, air, earth, respectively; the
last four respectively with the elements--water, air, earth, fire. This
is ingenious, if not altogether convincing.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account