Now when a speech is merely in conformity with the principles and rules
of the language, without having sweetness, beauty, polish, and
embellishment, in the simple and complex forms, and is not free from
superfluity or excessive brevity compared with the meaning intended to
be conveyed, such a discourse is said to be merely grammatical; the man
who essentially and constantly speaks in that manner is said to be a
grammarian; and the power by which he speaks in that manner is called
grammar. When the speech also has sweetness, beauty, polish, and
embellishment, in the simple and complex forms, it is said to be
rhetorical (it is derived from the expression: ‘How sweet are Thy words
unto my palate!’[227] which signifies: how sweet and pleasant are
they!); the author of such a speech is called a rhetorician, provided
that this manner of speech is essential and constant with him; and the
capacity which he has for such a speech is called rhetoric. If in
addition to all these characteristics, the speech is also metrical, it
is called a poem; its author is called a poet, provided this is
essential and constant with him; and the capacity which he possesses for
that is called poetry. By the word ‘metre’ I mean to say that the
portions of the discourse are equal in the number of their vowels (thou
already knowest about that). This is called a poem, because by means of
the metre it is possible to sing it aloud. The term ‘poem’ has also been
applied to anything that is to be understood allegorically, as, for
instance, the Song of Songs, and others. The rhetorical discourses and
poems of the Jews have a special characteristic which I have not seen or
heard in the discourses and poems of other nations. The Jewish
rhetoricians and poets add sweetness, beauty, and polish to their
sentences by giving their rhetorical discourses and poems the form of
the scriptural verses and of the sayings of the wise and by their
endeavoring that that form should agree with the meaning of their
discourses, either according to the plain meaning of the Bible, or
according to some figurative application which they put into the
discourse. It is the highest degree of elegance and beauty in rhetoric
and rhetoricians when they make their discourses to be in harmony with,
and add to them sweetness from, the divine speech. This is due to the
circumstance that the Hebrew tongue is now deficient, as was explained,
and therefore the rhetoricians, when they wish to render their
discourses sweet and elegant, find it necessary to embellish and
beautify them with the rhetorical expressions that exist. Accordingly,
their loss is cancelled by their gain, and their deficiency turned to
advantage. I have likewise noticed that the Jewish rhetoricians possess
another peculiarity not shared by the rhetoricians of other nations: the
knowledge of grammar comes to them naturally, and their discourses are
always in conformity with the principles and rules of the science of
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account