English poetry -- 19th century -- History and criticism; Pre-Raphaelitism in literature
Very much more easy to understand are the stanzas upon "Earth and Man."
These attempt to explain the real problem of man's existence. The poet
represents the earth as a person, a mother, a nurse. But this mother,
this nurse, this divine person is not able to do everything for man.
She can give him life; she can feed him; but she cannot help him
otherwise, except upon the strange condition that he helps himself. She
makes him and embraces him, but that is all. Otherwise he must make his
own future, his own happiness or misery.
For he is in the lists
Contentious with the elements, whose dower
First sprang him; for swift vultures to devour
If he desists.
His breath of instant thirst
Is warning of a creature matched with strife,
To meet it as a bride, or let fall life
On life's accursed.
That is, man in this world is like an athlete, or a warrior in the
lists--in the place of contests. With what must he contend? First of
all, he must contend with the very elements of nature, with the very
same forces which brought him into being, or as the poet says "sprang
him." And if he hesitates to fight with those forces, then quickly the
vultures of death seize upon him. The condition of his existence is
struggle. Even the first cry of the child, the cry of thirst for the
mother's milk, signifies that man is born to desire and to toil and to
contend. He must either meet the duty of struggle as gladly as he would
meet a bride, or he must acknowledge himself unfit to live, and cursed
by his own mother, Nature. Nature is not to be thought of as a mother
that pets her child and weeps over its small sorrows; no, she is a good
mother, but very rough, and she loves only the child that fights and
conquers.
She has no pity upon him except as he fights and wins. She cannot do
certain things for him; she cannot develop his mind--he must do that
for himself. She makes him do it by pain, by terror, by punishing him
fearfully for his mistakes. By the consequence of mistakes only does
she teach him. She urges him forward by hunger and by fear, but there
is no mercy for him if he blunders. I want you to remember that the
poet is not speaking of the separate individual man, but of mankind and
of the history of the human race. According to modern science, man was
at the beginning nothing more than an animal; he has become what he is
through knowledge of suffering, and the poet describes his sufferings
in the beginning:
By hunger sharply sped
To grasp at weapons ere he learns their use,
In each new ring he bears a giant's thews,
An infant's head.
And ever that old task
Of reading what he is and whence he came,
Whither to go, finds wilder letters flame
Across her mask.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account