Art, Prehistoric; Folk literature -- History and criticism
Recent attempts have been made to raise to a general principle this
point of view which, with due caution, may be applied here and
there. Herbert Spinden in his reconstruction of American prehistoric
chronology, Alfred Kroeber in his analysis of cultural forms of the
Pacific Coast, and quite recently Clark Wissler have built up, founded
on this principle a system of historic sequences that appear to me
as quite untenable. That widely distributed cultural traits develop
special forms in each particular area is a truism that does not
require any proof. That these local developments may be arranged in
a chronological series, that those of the most limited distribution
are the youngest, is only partially true. It is not difficult to find
phenomena that center in a certain region and dwindle down at the
outskirts, but it is not true that these invariably arise on an ancient
substratum. The converse is often true, that an idea emanating from a
center is diffused over a wide area. Neither may the origin always be
looked for in the area of the strongest development. In the same way
as we find animals surviving and flourishing in regions far distant
from the locality in which they developed, so cultural traits may be
transferred and find their highest expression in regions far away from
their origin. The bronze castings of Benin; the wood carvings of New
Zealand; the bronze work of ancient Scandinavia; the giant stone work
of Easter Island; the early cultural development of Ireland and its
influences over Europe are examples of this kind.
Equally unsafe are the methods used by Fritz Graebner and Pater W.
Schmidt who claim the stability of certain very old and, as I fear,
fictitious correlations between cultural traits.
It is probably not necessary to point out the utter inadequacy of
Elliott Smith’s attempt to reduce all ethnological phenomena to a
single, and anthropologically speaking, late source and to assume a
permanence of cultural forms that exists nowhere.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account