Primitive Athens as described by ThucydidesHarrison, Jane Ellen
History
Primitive Athens as described by Thucydides
Harrison, Jane Ellen
Athens (Greece) -- Antiquities; Athens (Greece) -- Description and travel
Misunderstanding as regards the duplicated sanctuaries was explicable,
even natural, but the downward road once embarked on leads to a deeper
depth. Those who believe that Thucydides is concerned to prove that
the ancient city lay Southwards have to find for the Fair-Fount and
Nine-Spouts of Thucydides a home other than the rock of the Pnyx; they
place the ancient city well, whence the king’s daughters drew their
water, outside, not only of the walls of Themistocles, but even of the
later and wider enclosure of Hadrian; they place it on the Ilissus, at a
distance of over half-a-mile as the crow flies from the citadel gate. If
the king’s daughters really ventured out there we must not, considering
the convention of the times, too severely blame the attacks of the rude
Pelasgians. And assuredly, if any one will try the experiment of carrying
a bucket of water from Kallirrhoë on the Ilissus to the top of the
Acropolis on a hot summer’s day, he will imagine those king’s daughters
as cast in more than mortal mould.
In the days when the Kallirrhoë of Thucydides could be placed on the
Ilissus the conception of Athens formed by scholars was of an Athens in
the days of Pericles. To speak of ancient Athens as a ‘Mycenaean’ city
would then have been unmeaning, if not positively insulting. As soon as
we realise the conditions of a Pelasgian burgh, with its king and his
immediate dependents massed upon and close up to the citadel, we know
that the citadel-well _must_ be close at hand—the Fair-Fount of the Pnyx
is already full far.
As to the Fair-Fount (Kallirrhoë) on the Ilissus, there has been and
still prevails much confusion. A Kallirrhoë there certainly is on the
Ilissus; the women of Athens wash their clothes there to-day[333], and
the existence of this Kallirrhoë Prof. Dörpfeld has never denied. Nay, he
expressly points out that even in the days of Thucydides the Kallirrhoë
of the Pnyx had already lost its name, and needs to be recalled to his
readers. If, as has been seen, many sanctuaries were transferred and
names duplicated there is nothing (1) impossible nor (2) injurious to
our theory, if the new Kallirrhoë was sometimes, like its old archetype,
called Enneakrounos. Though as a matter of fact this seems not to have
been the case.
* * * * *
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account