=104.= It follows also that we have no reason to presume, as
has commonly been done, that the exercise of virtue in the
performance of ‘duties’ is ever good in itself--far less, that
it is the sole good: 173
=105.= and, if we consider the intrinsic value of such
exercise, it will appear (1) that, in most cases, it has no
value, and (2) that even the cases, where it has some value,
are far from constituting the sole good. The truth of the
latter proposition is generally inconsistently implied, even by
those who deny it; 174
=106.= but in order fairly to decide upon the intrinsic value
of virtue, we must distinguish three different kinds of
disposition, each of which is commonly so called and has been
maintained to be the only kind deserving the name. Thus (_a_)
the mere unconscious ‘habit’ of performing duties, which is the
commonest type, has no intrinsic value whatsoever; Christian
moralists are right in implying that mere ‘external rightness’
has no intrinsic value, though they are wrong in saying that it
is therefore not ‘virtuous,’ since this implies that it has no
value even as a means: 175
=107.= (_b_) where virtue consists in a disposition to have,
and be moved by, a sentiment of love towards really good
consequences of an action and of hatred towards really evil
ones, it has some intrinsic value, but its value may vary
greatly in degree: 177
=108.= finally (_c_) where virtue consists in
‘conscientiousness,’ _i.e._ the disposition not to act, in
certain cases, until we believe and feel that our action is
right, it seems to have some intrinsic value: the value of this
feeling has been peculiarly emphasized by Christian Ethics, but
it certainly is not, as Kant would lead us to think, either the
sole thing of value, or always good even as a means. 178
=109.= Summary of chapter. 180
CHAPTER VI.
THE IDEAL.
=110.= By an ‘ideal’ state of things may be meant either (1)
the Summum Bonum or absolutely best, or (2) the best which the
laws of nature allow to exist in this world, or (3) anything
greatly good in itself: this chapter will be principally
occupied with what is ideal in sense (3)--with answering the
fundamental question of Ethics; 183
=111.= but a correct answer to this question is an essential
step towards a correct view as to what is ‘ideal’ in senses (1)
and (2). 184
=112.= In order to obtain a correct answer to the question
‘What is good in itself?’ we must consider what value things
would have if they existed absolutely by themselves; 187
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account