Recollections of Dante Gabriel RossettiCaine, Hall, Sir
Philosophy
Recollections of Dante Gabriel Rossetti
Caine, Hall, Sir
Rossetti, Dante Gabriel, 1828-1882
In all humility I regard his depreciatory opinion, not at all as a
valuable example of literary judgment, but as indicative of a clear
radical difference of poetic bias between the two poets, such as must
in the same way have made Wordsworth resist Rossetti if he had appeared
before him. I am the more confirmed in this view from the circumstance
that Rossetti, throughout the period of my acquaintance with him, seemed
to me always peculiarly and, if I may be permitted to say so without
offence, strangely liable to Mr. Watts’s influence in his critical
estimates, and that the case instanced was perhaps the only one in
which I knew him to resist Mr. Watts’s opinion upon a matter of poetical
criticism, which he considered to be almost final, as his letters to
me, printed in Chapter VIII. of this volume, will show. I had a striking
instance of this, and of the real modesty of the man whom I had heard
and still hear spoken of as the most arrogant man of genius of his
day, on one of the first occasions of my seeing him. He read out to me
an additional stanza to the beautiful poem _Cloud Confines_: As he
read it, I thought it very fine, and he evidently was very fond of it
himself. But he surprised me by saying that he should not print it. On
my asking him why, he said:
“Watts, though he admits its beauty, thinks the poem would be better
without it.”
“Well, but you like it yourself,” said I.
“Yes,” he replied; “but in a question of gain or loss to a poem, I feel
that Watts must be right.”
And the poem appeared in _Ballads and Sonnets_ without the stanza in
question. The same thing occurred with regard to the omission of the
sonnet _Nuptial Sleep_ from the new edition of the Poems in 1881. Mr.
Watts took the view (to Rossetti’s great vexation at first) that this
sonnet, howsoever perfect in structure and beautiful from the artistic
point of view, was “out of place and altogether incongruous in a group
of sonnets so entirely spiritual as _The House of Life_,” and Rossetti
gave way: but upon the subject of Wordsworth in his relations to
Coleridge, Keats, and Shelley, he was quite inflexible to the last.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account