Reflections on the painting and sculpture of the Greeks : $b with instructions for the connoisseur, and an essay on grace in works of artWinckelmann, Johann Joachim
Philosophy
Reflections on the painting and sculpture of the Greeks : $b with instructions for the connoisseur, and an essay on grace in works of art
Winckelmann, Johann Joachim
Aesthetics -- Early works to 1800; Art -- Philosophy; Art, Greek
The third mentioned some heads of Livia and Agrippina, without that
pretended profile of yours. Here he thinks you had the most lucky
occasion to talk of that kind of nose by the ancients called _Quadrata_,
as an ingredient of beauty. But you no doubt know, that the noses of
some of the most famous Greek statues, viz. the Medicean Venus, and
the Picchinian Meleager, are much too thick for becoming the model of
beauty, in that kind, to our artists.
I shall not, however, gall you with all the doubts and objections
raised against your treatise, and repeated to nauseousness, upon the
arrival of an Academician, the Margites of our days, who, being shewed
your treatise, gave it a slight glance, then laid it aside, offended
as it were at first sight. But it was easy to perceive that he wanted
his opinion to be asked, which we accordingly all did. “The author,
said he very peremptorily, seems not to have been at much pains with
this treatise: I cannot find above four or five quotations, and those
negligently inserted; no chapter, no page, cited; he certainly collected
his remarks from books which he is ashamed to produce.”
Yet cannot I help introducing another gentleman, sharp-sighted enough
to pick out something that had escaped all my attention; viz. that the
Greeks were the first inventors of Painting and Sculpture; an assertion,
as he was pleased to express himself, entirely false, having been told it
was the Egyptians, or some people still more ancient, and unknown to him.
Even the most whimsical humour may be turned to profit: nevertheless, I
think it manifest that you intended to talk only of good Taste in those
arts; and the first Elements of an art have the same proportion to good
Taste in it, as the seed has to the fruit. That the art was still in its
infancy among the Egyptians, when it had attained the highest degree of
perfection among the Greeks, may be seen by examining one single gem:
you need only consider the head of _Ptolomæus Philopator_ by Aulus, and
the two figures adjoining to it done by an Egyptian[18], in order to be
convinced of the little merit this nation could pretend to in point of
art.
The form and taste of their Painting have been ascertained by
Middleton.[19] The pictures of persons as big as life, on two mummies
in the royal cabinet of antiquities at Dresden, are evident instances
of their incapacity. But these relicks being curious, in several other
respects, I shall hereafter subjoin a short account of them.
I cannot, my friend, help allowing some reason for several of these
objections. Your negligence in your quotations was, no doubt, somewhat
prejudicial to your authenticity: the art of changing blue eyes to black
ones, certainly deserved an authority. You imitate Democritus; who
being asked, “What is man?” every body knows what was his reply. What
reasonable creature will submit to read all Greek scholiasts!
_Ibit eo, quo vis, qui Zonam perdidit_—
Hor.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account