Reflections on the painting and sculpture of the Greeks : $b with instructions for the connoisseur, and an essay on grace in works of artWinckelmann, Johann Joachim
Philosophy
Reflections on the painting and sculpture of the Greeks : $b with instructions for the connoisseur, and an essay on grace in works of art
Winckelmann, Johann Joachim
Aesthetics -- Early works to 1800; Art -- Philosophy; Art, Greek
Considering, however, how easily the human mind is biassed, either by
friendship or animosity, I took occasion from these objections to examine
your treatise with more exactness; and shall now, by the most impartial
censure, strive to clear myself from every imputation of prepossession in
your favour.
I will pass by the first and second page, though something might
be said on your comparison of the Diana with the Nausicaa, and the
application: nor would it have been amiss, had you thrown some more light
on the remark concerning the misused pictures of Corregio (very likely
borrowed from Count Tessin’s letters), by giving an account of the other
indignities which the pictures of the best artists, at the same time, met
with at Stockholm.
It is well known that, after the surrender of Prague to Count Konigsmark,
the 15th of July 1648, the most precious pictures of the Emperor Rodolph
II. were carried off to Sweden[20]. Among these were some pictures
of Corregio, which the Emperor had been presented with by their first
possessor, Duke Frederick of Mantua; two of them being the famous Leda,
and a Cupid handling his bow[21]. Christina, endowed at that time rather
with scholastic learning than taste, treated these treasures as the
Emperor Claudius did an Alexander of Apelles; who ordered the head to be
cut off, and that of Augustus to fill its place[22]. In the same manner
heads, hands, feet were here cut off from the most beautiful pictures;
a carpet was plastered over with them, and the mangled pieces fitted up
with new heads, &c. Those that fortunately escaped the common havock,
among which were the pieces of Corregio, came afterwards, together with
several other pictures, bought by the Queen at Rome, into the possession
of the Duke of Orleans, who purchased 250 of them, and among those eleven
of Corregio, for 9000 Roman crowns.
But I am not contented with your charging only the northern countries
with barbarism, on account of the little esteem they paid to the arts.
If good taste is to be judged in this manner, I am afraid for our French
neighbours. For having taken Bonn, the residence of the Elector of
Cologne, after the death of Max. Henry, they ordered the largest pictures
to be cut out of their frames, without distinction, in order to serve for
coverings to the waggons, in which the most valuable furniture of the
electoral castle was carried off for France. But, Sir, do not presume
on my continuing with mere historical remarks: I shall proceed with my
objections; after making the two following general observations.
I. You have written in a style too concise for being distinct. Were
you afraid of being condemned to the penalty of a Spartan, who could
not restrain himself to only three words, perhaps that of reading
Picciardin’s Pisan War? Distinctness is required where universal
instruction is the end. Meats are to suit the taste of the guests, rather
than that of the cooks,
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account