Reflections on the painting and sculpture of the Greeks : $b with instructions for the connoisseur, and an essay on grace in works of artWinckelmann, Johann Joachim
Philosophy
Reflections on the painting and sculpture of the Greeks : $b with instructions for the connoisseur, and an essay on grace in works of art
Winckelmann, Johann Joachim
Aesthetics -- Early works to 1800; Art -- Philosophy; Art, Greek
It is in general to be observed, first, that this kind of sculpture
admits not indifferently of every attitude and action; as for instance,
of too strong projections of the legs. Secondly, That, besides disposing
of the several modelled figures in well-ranged groupes, the diameter of
every one ought to be applied to the bas-relief itself, by a lessened
scale: as for instance, the diameter of a figure in the model being one
foot, the profile of the same, according to its size, will be three
inches, or less: the rounder a figure of that diameter, the greater the
skill. Commonly the relief wants perspective, and thence arise most of
its faults.
Though I proposed to make only a few remarks on the ancient bas-relief,
I find myself, like a certain ancient Rhetor, almost under a necessity
of being new-tuned. I have strayed beyond my limits; though at the same
time I remembered that there is a law among commentators, to content
themselves with bare remarks on the contents of a treatise: and also
sensible that I am writing a letter, not a book, I consider that I may
draw some instructions for my own use,
——_ut vineta egomet cædam mea,_
Hor.
from some peoples impetuosity against the author; who, because they are
hired for it, seem to think that writing is confined to them alone.
The Romans, though they worshipped the deity Terminus (the guardian God
of limits and borders in general; and, if it please these gentlemen, of
the limits in arts and sciences too), allowed nevertheless an universal
unrestrained criticism: and the decisions of some Greeks and Romans,
in matters of an art, which they did not practise, seem nevertheless
authentick to our artists.
Nor can I find, that the keeper of the temple of peace at Rome, though
possessed of the register of the pictures there, pretended to monopolize
remarks and criticisms upon them; Pliny having described most of them.
_Publica materies privati juris sit_—
Hor.
’Tis to be wished, that, roused by a Pamphilus and an Apelles, artists
would take up the pen themselves, in order to discover the mysteries of
the art to those that know how to use them,
_Ma di costor’, che à lavorar s’accingono,_
_Quattro quinti, per Dio, non sanno leggere._
Salvator Rosa, Sat. III.
Two or three of these are to be commended; the rest contented themselves
with giving some historical accounts of the fraternity. But what could
appear more auspicious to the improvement of the art, even by the
remotest posterity, than the work attempted by the united forces of the
celebrated Pietro da Cortona[42] and Padre Ottonelli? Nevertheless this
same treatise, except only a few historical remarks, and these too to be
met with in an hundred books, seems good for nothing, but
_Ne scombris tunicæ desint, piperique cuculli._
Sectan. Sat.
How trivial, how mean are the great _Poussin_’s reflexions on painting,
published by Bellori, and annexed to his life of that artist[43]?
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account