Reflections on the painting and sculpture of the Greeks : $b with instructions for the connoisseur, and an essay on grace in works of art — John Shaqi
Reflections on the painting and sculpture of the Greeks : $b with instructions for the connoisseur, and an essay on grace in works of artWinckelmann, Johann Joachim
Philosophy
Reflections on the painting and sculpture of the Greeks : $b with instructions for the connoisseur, and an essay on grace in works of art
Winckelmann, Johann Joachim
Aesthetics -- Early works to 1800; Art -- Philosophy; Art, Greek
Another digression!—let me now again resume the character of your
Aristarchus.
You are bold enough to attack the authority of _Bernini_, and to
challenge a man, the bare mention of whose name would do honour to any
treatise. It was _Bernini_, you ought to recollect, Sir, who at the
same age in which Michael Angelo performed his _Studiolo_[44], viz. in
his eighteenth year, produced his Daphne, as a convincing instance of
his intimacy with the ancients, at an age in which perhaps the genius of
Raphael was yet labouring under darkness and ignorance!
_Bernini_ was one of those favourites of nature, who produce at the same
time vernal blossoms and autumnal fruits; and I think it by no means
probable, that his studying nature in riper years misled either him
or his disciples. The smoothness of his flesh was the result of that
study, and imparted to the marble the highest possible degree of life
and beauty. Indeed ’tis nature which endows art with life, and “vivifies
forms,” as Socrates says[45], and Clito the sculptor allows. The great
Lysippus, when asked which of his ancestors he had chosen for his
master, replied, “None; but nature alone.” It is not to be denied, that
the too close imitation of antiquity is very often apt to lead us to a
certain barrenness, unknown to those who imitate nature: various herself,
nature teaches variety, and no votary of her’s can be charged with a
sameness: whereas Guido, Le Brun, and some other votaries of antiquity,
repeated the same face in many of their works. A certain ideal beauty was
become so familiar to them, as to slide into their figures even against
their will.
But as for such an imitation of nature, as is quite regardless of
antiquity, I am entirely of the author’s opinion; though I should have
chosen other artists as instances of following nature in painting.
_Jordans_ certainly has not met with the regard due to his merit; let
me appeal to an authority universally allowed. “There is, says Mr.
d’Argenville, more expression and truth in Jordans, than even in Rubens.
“Truth is the basis and origin of perfection and beauty; nothing, of any
kind whatever, can be beautiful or perfect, without being truly what it
ought to be, without having all it ought to have.”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account