Reflections on the painting and sculpture of the Greeks : $b with instructions for the connoisseur, and an essay on grace in works of artWinckelmann, Johann Joachim
Philosophy
Reflections on the painting and sculpture of the Greeks : $b with instructions for the connoisseur, and an essay on grace in works of art
Winckelmann, Johann Joachim
Aesthetics -- Early works to 1800; Art -- Philosophy; Art, Greek
The distances behind the figures represent a magnificent Greek building,
whose decorations seem allegorical. The roof of a portal is supported
by Cariatides embracing each other, as images of the tender friendship
between father and son, and alluding, at the same time, to the nuptial
ceremony.
Though faithful to history, the painter was nevertheless a poet: in
order to represent some circumstances, he filled even the furniture with
sentiments. The Sphinxes by the Prince’s bed allude to his problematic
sickness, the enquiries of Erasistratus, and his sagacity in discovering
its true cause.
I have been told that some young Italian artists, when considering this
picture, and perceiving the Prince’s arm perhaps a trifle too big, went
off without enquiring into the subject itself. Should even Minerva
herself, as she once did to Diomedes, attempt to deliver some people from
the mist they labour under, by heaven! the attempt were vain!
——_pauci dignoscere possunt_
_Vera bona, atque illis multum diversa, remota_
_Erroris nebula._
Juv. X.
I have run into this long digression, in order to throw some light on one
of the first productions of the art, which is nevertheless but little
known.
The idea of noble simplicity and sedate grandeur in Raphael’s figures,
might rather, as two eminent authors express it[55], be called “still
life.” It is indeed the standard of the Greek art: however, indiscreetly
commended to young artists, it might beget as dangerous consequences, as
precepts of energetick conciseness in the style; the direct method to
make it barren and unpleasing.
“In youths, says Cicero[56], there must be some superfluity, something
to be taken off: prematurity spoils the juices, and it is easier to lop
the young rank branches of a vine, than to restore its vigour to a worn
out trunk.” Not to mention, that figures wanting gesture would, by the
bulk of mankind, be received as a speech before the Areopagites, where,
by a severe law, the speaker was forbid to raise any passions, though
ever so gentle[57]: nay, pictures of this kind would be so many portraits
of young Spartans, who, with hands hid under their coats, and down-cast
eyes, stalk forth in silent solemnity[58].
Neither am I quite of the author’s opinion with regard to allegory; the
applying of which would too frequently do in painting, what was done in
geometry by introducing algebra: the one would soon be as difficult as
the other, and painting would degenerate into Hieroglyphicks.
The author attempts, in vain, to persuade us, that the majority of the
Greeks thought as the Egyptians. There was no more learning in the
painting of the platfond of the temple of Juno at Samos, than in that
of the Farnese gallery. It represented the love-intrigues of Jupiter
and Juno[59]: and, in the front of a temple of Ceres at Eleusis, there
was nothing but representations of a ceremony at the rites of that
goddess[60].
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account