Reginald Bateman, Teacher and Soldier: A Memorial Volume of Selections from His Lectures and Other Writings — John Shaqi
Reginald Bateman, Teacher and Soldier: A Memorial Volume of Selections from His Lectures and Other WritingsBateman, Reginald
History
Reginald Bateman, Teacher and Soldier: A Memorial Volume of Selections from His Lectures and Other Writings
Bateman, Reginald
Bateman, Reginald, 1884?-1918; English literature -- History and criticism; World War, 1914-1918
The analysis will include a treatment not only of the literary form of
the poem, but a thorough study of its language, of the historical and
literary allusions contained in it, of any images or metaphors which
may be obscure, and, in fact, anything which will contribute to a
better understanding of the poem as a whole. The teacher will now
probably ask: "How far is this process of analysis to go? Must one
study the philology of every word, must one analyse the metre of every
poem?" I have already given the answer to these questions. I said
that the analysis would include a study of anything which _will
contribute to the better understanding of the poem as a whole_. There
is the secret. The total effect must never be lost sight of. The
metre is to be studied only to an extent which will enable the student
to catch the rhythm and read the poem correctly for himself. Names and
technicalities matter not a whit. He may never have heard of an iambic
pentameter, or an anapaest, or a trochee, but as long as he grasps the
rhythm and sees the relations of the various parts of the literary
structure, he knows all that is necessary for a thorough appreciation
of the poem as a whole. Similarly, the derivation of a word should
never be given unless it helps to the better understanding of the sense
of the word _as that word is used in the particular passage under
discussion_; otherwise the obtrusion of the etymology is simply an
impertinence.
Some teachers make interpretation by paraphrase a prominent part of
this analytical process; this should be avoided. It may be necessary
sometimes to paraphrase difficult passages, but not one-tenth as often
as most teachers and editors consider it necessary. A paraphrase is at
best an inferior rendering, a substitution of something similar, but of
a lower kind, often a substitution of the baldest prose for the highest
poetry. "I pray thee avoid it." Some editors are over-fond of
analysis; probably because they wish to show they are earning the money
they get for editing. Let the poem, as far as possible, tell its own
story in its own words.
When the analytic or discursive process has been completed, what
remains? A return to the general. Having considered the poem in its
parts, one now endeavours to reproduce the effect of the poem as a
whole, but this time, if the analysis has been well done, the effect
ought to be greatly heightened. The student will now see, not through
a glass darkly, but will meet the poet face to face.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account