Remarks upon the proposed destruction of the tower of the Parish Church of St. John, Hampstead — John Shaqi
Remarks upon the proposed destruction of the tower of the Parish Church of St. John, HampsteadScott, George Gilbert, Sir
History
Remarks upon the proposed destruction of the tower of the Parish Church of St. John, Hampstead
Scott, George Gilbert, Sir
Church architecture -- England -- London; St. John's Parish Church (Hampstead, London, England)
If those who are anxious for proper chancel arrangements should be
dissatisfied with a Quire marked off by screens, there is another mode of
extending the Church, by which a constructional chancel and the
fashionable apse may be obtained. I am, so far, however, from
sympathising with this feeling, that in large town churches I distinctly
prefer what may be termed the Basilican arrangement. I consider that a
chancel distinguished by a proper number of steps and by screens behind
the stalls, is far preferable, in a town church, to one formed in the
construction of the building, involving as this does massive piers,
obstructive to sight and sound. With a chancel constructed as the
Trustees propose, the great majority of persons seated in the aisles will
see little or nothing of the choir. I consider this a very serious
defect. If the congregation is to sing with the choir, as we all desire,
it is of the greatest importance that we should be able to see as well as
hear. For the real uses of a modern church the interior cannot be too
unobstructed, and it seems to me a retrograde movement to attempt to
convert a church, which, but for the galleries, is singularly open and
thoroughly congregational, into one in which at least one third of the
people would not see nearly so well as they do at present.
Should, however, the opposite view unfortunately prevail, and a
“constructional chancel” and an “apsidal termination” be decided on,
there is no difficulty at all in providing for them upon the principle of
a westward extension.
I should propose in this case simply to reverse the church, and to place
the new chancel and apse at the west end. The tower would thus remain as
it is, but I should advise that a central entrance should be formed
through it, where the present vestry is. A second tower might be erected
if funds allow, over the new chancel, with all the advantages of position
upon which I have already dwelt in describing the former plan. Spacious
vestries might be formed at the side of the new chancel, or if preferred,
below it, for which the fall of the ground and the ascent to the chancel
would give ample height. A very fine effect might be obtained by
ascending to the chancel in the centre and descending on either side to
the vestries below.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account