Research methods in ecologyClements, Frederic E. (Frederic Edward)
Science
Research methods in ecology
Clements, Frederic E. (Frederic Edward)
Plant ecology; Plant ecology -- Methodology
=19. Taxonomy.= Taxonomy is classified evolution. It is distinct from
descriptive botany, which is merely a cataloguing of all known forms,
with little regard to development and relationship. The consideration of
the latter is peculiarly the problem of taxonomy, but the solution must
be sought through experimental evolution. The first task of the latter
is to determine the course of modification in related forms, and the
relationships existing between them. With this information, taxonomy can
group forms according to their rank, i. e., their descent. The same
method is applicable to the species of a genus, and, in a less degree,
perhaps, to the genera which constitute a family. The use to which it
may be put in indicating family relationships will depend largely upon
the gap existing between the families concerned. While interpretation
will always play a part in taxonomy, the general use of experiment will
leave much less opportunity for the personal equation than is at present
the case. Taxonomy, like descriptive botany, is based upon the species,
but, while there may exist a passable kind of descriptive botany, there
can be no real taxonomy as long as the sole criterion of a species is
the difference which any observer thinks he sees between one plant and
another. The so-called species of to-day range in value from mere
variations to true species which are groups of great constancy and
definiteness. The reasons for this are obvious when one recalls that
“species” are still the product of the herbarium, not of the field, and
that the more intensive the study, the greater the output in “species.”
It would seem that careful field study of a form for several seasons
would be the first requisite for the making of a species, but it is a
precaution which is entirely ignored in the vast majority of cases. The
thought of subjecting forms presumed to be species to conclusive test by
experiment has apparently not even occurred to descriptive botanists as
yet. Notwithstanding, there can be no serious doubt that the existing
practice of re-splitting hairs must come to an end sooner or later. The
remedy will come from without through the application of experimental
methods in the hands of the ecologist, and the cataloguing of slight and
unrelated differences will yield to an ordered taxonomy.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account