If it were established even that the criminal type is inferior mentally
and physically and that they have all misshapen heads, this alone ought
to be sufficient to raise the inquiry as to who was responsible for their
acts. Long ago a wise man said that no one could by taking thought add a
cubit to his stature, and yet we hang and pen because these unfortunates
have not grown as tall, as large, or as symmetrical as the ordinary
man. But the mental actions of man have been shown to be as much due to
law and environment as his physical health,—certain sections of the
world are indigenous to men who kill their fellows; and more than this,
certain portions produce men who kill with guns, others who kill with
a knife, others still who administer poison. In certain sections, the
chief crime is horse stealing; in others, running illicit distilleries;
again, burglary; in some places, poaching; sometimes, robbery; and
again, smuggling. A study of conditions would reveal why each of those
crimes is indigenous to the particular soil that gives them birth, and
just as draining swamps prevents the miasma, so a rational treatment
of the condition caused by the various crimes would cure them, too. If
our physicians were no more intelligent than our lawyers, when called
to visit a miasmic patient, instead of draining the swamp they would
chloroform the patient and expect thus to frighten all others from taking
the disease.
Observation as to so-called crime has gone much further. The number of
inmates of our jails is much larger in winter than in summer, which
ought to show that there is something in the air that produces a wicked
heart in the winter, or that many persons directly or indirectly go to
jail because in winter, food and warmth are not easily obtained and
work is hard to get. For many years it has been observed that jails are
very much more crowded in hard times than in good times. If work were
sufficiently plenty or remunerative both jails and almshouses would
be compelled to close their doors. Long ago it was ascertained from
statistics that the number of crimes rose and fell in exact accord with
the price of bread. All new communities, where land is cheap or free and
labor has ample employment, or, better still, a chance to employ itself,
are very free from crime. England made Australia its dumping ground for
criminals for years, but these same criminals when turned upon the wide
plains with a chance to get their living from the soil, became peaceable,
orderly citizens fully respecting one another’s rights. England, too,
used certain portions of her American colonies where she sent men for
her country’s good. These criminals like all the criminals of the world
were the exploited, homeless class. When they reached the new country,
when they had an opportunity to live, they became as good citizens as the
pilgrim fathers who were likewise criminals themselves. As civilization
has swept westward through the United States, jails have lagged behind.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account