Saint Joan : $b A chronicle play in six scenes and an epilogueShaw, Bernard
HistoryHistory
Saint Joan : $b A chronicle play in six scenes and an epilogue
Shaw, Bernard
Christian women saints -- Drama; France -- History -- Charles VII, 1422-1461 -- Drama; Joan, of Arc, Saint, 1412-1431 -- Drama
As she contrived to assert herself in all these ways with such force
that she was famous throughout western Europe before she was out of her
teens (indeed she never got out of them), it is hardly surprising that
she was judicially burnt, ostensibly for a number of capital crimes
which we no longer punish as such, but essentially for what we call
unwomanly and insufferable presumption. At eighteen Joan’s pretensions
were beyond those of the proudest Pope or the haughtiest emperor. She
claimed to be the ambassador and plenipotentiary of God, and to be, in
effect, a member of the Church Triumphant whilst still in the flesh on
earth. She patronized her own king, and summoned the English king to
repentance and obedience to her commands. She lectured, talked down, and
overruled statesmen and prelates. She poohpoohed the plans of generals,
leading their troops to victory on plans of her own. She had an
unbounded and quite unconcealed contempt for official opinion, judgment,
and authority, and for War Office tactics and strategy. Had she been a
sage and monarch in whom the most venerable hierarchy and the most
illustrious dynasty converged, her pretensions and proceedings would
have been as trying to the official mind as the pretensions of Caesar
were to Cassius. As her actual condition was pure upstart, there were
only two opinions about her. One was that she was miraculous: the other
that she was unbearable.
Joan and Socrates.
If Joan had been malicious, selfish, cowardly or stupid, she would have
been one of the most odious persons known to history instead of one of
the most attractive. If she had been old enough to know the effect she
was producing on the men whom she humiliated by being right when they
were wrong, and had learned to flatter and manage them, she might have
lived as long as Queen Elizabeth. But she was too young and rustical and
inexperienced to have any such arts. When she was thwarted by men whom
she thought fools, she made no secret of her opinion of them or her
impatience with their folly; and she was naïve enough to expect them to
be obliged to her for setting them right and keeping them out of
mischief. Now it is always hard for superior wits to understand the fury
roused by their exposures of the stupidities of comparative dullards.
Even Socrates, for all his age and experience, did not defend himself at
his trial like a man who understood the long accumulated fury that had
burst on him, and was clamoring for his death. His accuser, if born 2300
years later, might have been picked out of any first class carriage on a
suburban railway during the evening or morning rush from or to the City;
for he had really nothing to say except that he and his like could not
endure being shewn up as idiots every time Socrates opened his mouth.
Socrates, unconscious of this, was paralyzed by his sense that somehow
he was missing the point of the attack. He petered out after he had
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account