Saint Joan : $b A chronicle play in six scenes and an epilogue — John Shaqi
Saint Joan : $b A chronicle play in six scenes and an epilogueShaw, Bernard
HistoryHistory
Saint Joan : $b A chronicle play in six scenes and an epilogue
Shaw, Bernard
Christian women saints -- Drama; France -- History -- Charles VII, 1422-1461 -- Drama; Joan, of Arc, Saint, 1412-1431 -- Drama
established the fact that he was an old soldier and a man of honorable
life, and that his accuser was a silly snob. He had no suspicion of the
extent to which his mental superiority had roused fear and hatred
against him in the hearts of men towards whom he was conscious of
nothing but good will and good service.
Contrast with Napoleon.
If Socrates was as innocent as this at the age of seventy, it may be
imagined how innocent Joan was at the age of seventeen. Now Socrates was
a man of argument, operating slowly and peacefully on men’s minds,
whereas Joan was a woman of action, operating with impetuous violence on
their bodies. That, no doubt, is why the contemporaries of Socrates
endured him so long, and why Joan was destroyed before she was fully
grown. But both of them combined terrifying ability with a frankness,
personal modesty, and benevolence which made the furious dislike to
which they fell victims absolutely unreasonable, and therefore
inapprehensible by themselves. Napoleon, also possessed of terrifying
ability, but neither frank nor disinterested, had no illusions as to the
nature of his popularity. When he was asked how the world would take his
death, he said it would give a gasp of relief. But it is not so easy for
mental giants who neither hate nor intend to injure their fellows to
realize that nevertheless their fellows hate mental giants and would
like to destroy them, not only enviously because the juxtaposition of a
superior wounds their vanity, but quite humbly and honestly because it
frightens them. Fear will drive men to any extreme; and the fear
inspired by a superior being is a mystery which cannot be reasoned away.
Being immeasurable it is unbearable when there is no presumption or
guarantee of its benevolence and moral responsibility: in other words,
when it has no official status. The legal and conventional superiority
of Herod and Pilate, and of Annas and Caiphas, inspires fear; but the
fear, being a reasonable fear of measurable and avoidable consequences
which seem salutary and protective, is bearable; whilst the strange
superiority of Christ and the fear it inspires elicit a shriek of
Crucify Him from all who cannot divine its benevolence. Socrates has to
drink the hemlock, Christ to hang on the cross, and Joan to burn at the
stake, whilst Napoleon, though he ends in St Helena, at least dies in
his bed there; and many terrifying but quite comprehensible official
scoundrels die natural deaths in all the glory of the kingdoms of this
world, proving that it is far more dangerous to be a saint than to be a
conqueror. Those who have been both, like Mahomet and Joan, have found
that it is the conqueror who must save the saint, and that defeat and
capture mean martyrdom. Joan was burnt without a hand lifted on her own
side to save her. The comrades she had led to victory and the enemies
she had disgraced and defeated, the French king she had crowned and the
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account