Satire in the Victorian novelRussell, Frances Theresa
History
Satire in the Victorian novel
Russell, Frances Theresa
English fiction -- 19th century -- History and criticism; Satire, English -- History and criticism; Thesis (Ph. D.)
Butler’s publications, beginning two years after Peacock’s had
ended,[97] extended through the next half century, _The Way of All
Flesh_ and _Notebooks_ being posthumous. But the three decades
bracketed by the two Erewhons were the fertile ones. Through them
flowed steadily a stream of many currents; satiric, scientific
(mainly controversial), classic, critical, descriptive, expository,
musical, and artistic. Of all these volumes only three can be classed
as fiction, and one of those falls in the other group. Our present
interest centers upon _Erewhon_ and its sequel.
There is no more effective satiric machinery than that of the Foreign
State, or Adventures among Strange People. It may take the form of a
serious though perhaps fantastic conception with incidental satire,
as in _Utopia_, _New Atlantis_, _The Coming Race_, _Modern Utopia_;
or a travesty of these, an inverted pyramid, made grotesque by the
dominating satire, though none the less freighted with serious intent,
as _Gulliver_, _Journey from This World to the Next_, _Erewhon_.
From the fact that _The Coming Race_ and _Erewhon_ may be cited as
examples of the same literary genus, though of different species, comes
the suggestion that the real complement of Butler is Lytton. It does
happen that they furnish the only two instances on our list of the
exercise of this particular kind of creative fancy.[98] Lytton’s tale
pictures a positive ideal, which satirizes our inadequate reality by
acting as a foil to it. Butler’s narrative portrays a supposed reality,
of which the visitor does not approve; and his comments satirize our
accepted reality by a subtle, indirect reflection. Our race placed
beside the “coming” one merely looks small, inferior, incomplete, yet
all it needs is growth. But if the barrier could be leveled between
our country and the one Over the Range, the two would confront each
other and see their own images, not as in a glass darkly but as in a
brilliant yet tricky and distorting mirror. Our actual beliefs and
practices, shorn of the verbal illusions we have spun around them, and
pushed to their logical conclusions, would become the naked _reductio
ad absurdum_ we view in the Erewhonian philosophy of illness, crime,
science, religion, life, and death.[99]
In _Erewhon Revisited_ we see a mental sequence even more interesting
than the dramatic sequel. _Erewhon_ was followed the very next year by
_The Fair Haven_. The former supplies the stage setting, the latter the
central idea, whose combination makes the Revisit a seemingly artless
but really astounding _tour de force_, an uncanny offspring of logic
and fancy.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account