Schenk's Theory: The Determination of SexSchenk, Samuel Leopold
Science
Schenk's Theory: The Determination of Sex
Schenk, Samuel Leopold
Sex determination, Genetic; Sex preselection
What question is there of the present day, respecting which we can
consult the literature of the ancients, that does not take us back
to the writings of Hippocrates, Aristotle, or Galen, or to those of
the old authors of those oriental races whom we regard as the earliest
cultivated peoples? Hippocrates held that to produce a male, the
generative material must be of a stronger quality. The future destiny
of the male rendered it necessary that it should be constructed on
a stouter foundation. He must be capable of a stronger development,
and must, therefore, be a product of stronger elements alike on the
father’s and the mother’s side. A second hypothesis was soon added to
this primary one, but without any foundation of facts.
According to Aristotle, the woman supplied the primary material for
the development of the future individual. It was the function of the
man to give the impulse, in consequence of which the future individual
came into being. Next followed the purely mythical theory, already
mentioned, in which Anaxagoras believed. The much-sought-for origin of
the future difference of sex in the various individuals was assigned to
the right or left side of the organism. And Galen even concluded that
the right side of the body was the warmer, and the left the colder,
further claiming for the warmer side the privilege of producing male
individuals.
* * * * *
Various notions respecting the origin of sex have been also accommodated
to these primitive theories of the ancients, without resting upon any
positive foundation. No evidence exists to show from whom they
originated, nor how they were disseminated. Nevertheless, the historical
connection of these speculations justifies a reference to them, and
various hypotheses of this kind will be found in a little publication of
Dr. Heinrich Janke’s (Stuttgart, 1896). The older literature on the
subject of the generation of the sexes has been collected by His.
(_Archiv für Anthropologie, Vol. IV. V._) In ‘_Das Weib in der Natur
and Völkerkunde_’ (Leipzig), Ploss has collected ample information
concerning both ancient and modern ideas on this subject amongst the
different races of mankind. The procreative elements, furnished by the
male and female organs, after their mixture, compete with each other, by
virtue of their inherent forces, for the mastery. In this conflict, if
the male molecules are the more numerous, a male results. On the
contrary, if the female molecules are more numerous, the result is a
female. Nicholaus Venette ascribes the difference of sex to the
earliest phases of the life of the ovule.
* * * * *
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account