Science and poetryRichards, I. A. (Ivor Armstrong)
History
Science and poetry
Richards, I. A. (Ivor Armstrong)
English poetry -- 20th century -- History and criticism; Poetry
Mr. Yeats and Mr. Lawrence present two further ways of dodging those
difficulties which come from being born into this generation rather
than into some earlier age. Mr. De la Mare takes shelter in the
dream-world of the child, Mr. Yeats retires into black velvet curtains
and the visions of the Hermetist, and Mr. Lawrence makes a magnificent
attempt to reconstruct in himself the mentality of the Bushman. There
are other modes of escape open to the poet. Mr. Blundell, to name one
other poet only, goes into the country, but few people follow him there
in his spirit, whereas Mr. Yeats and Mr. Lawrence, whether they are
widely read or not, do represent tendencies among the defeated which
are only too easily observable.
Mr. Yeats’ work from the beginning was a repudiation of the most active
contemporary interests. But at first the poet of _The Wanderings
of Usheen_, _The Stolen Child_, and _Innisfree_ turned away from
contemporary civilization in favour of a world which he knew perfectly,
the world of folk-lore as it is accepted, neither with belief nor
disbelief, by the peasant. Folk-lore and the Irish landscape, its
winds, woods, waters, islets, and seagulls, and for a while an
unusually simple and direct kind of love poetry in which he became
something more than a minor poet, these were his refuge. Later, after
a drawn battle with the drama, he made a more violent repudiation,
not merely of current civilization but of life itself, in favour of a
supernatural world. But the world of the ‘eternal moods,’ of supernal
essences and immortal beings is not, like the Irish peasant stories
and the Irish landscape, part of his natural and familiar experience.
Now he turns to a world of symbolic phantasmagoria about which he is
desperately uncertain. He is uncertain because he has adopted as a
technique of inspiration the use of trance, of dissociated phases of
consciousness, and the revelations given in these dissociated states
are insufficiently connected with normal experience. This, in part,
explains the weakness of Mr. Yeats’ transcendental poetry. A deliberate
reversal of the natural relations of thought and feeling is the rest
of the explanation. Mr. Yeats takes certain feelings--feelings of
conviction attaching to certain visions--as evidence for the thoughts
which he supposes his visions to symbolize. To Mr. Yeats the value of
_The Phases of the Moon_ lies not in any attitudes which it arouses or
embodies but in the doctrine which for an initiate it promulgates.
The resort to trance, and the effort to discover a new world-picture to
replace that given by science are the two most significant points for
our purpose in Mr. Yeats’ work. A third might be the singularly bitter
contempt for the generality of mankind which occasionally appears.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account