Science and the modern worldWhitehead, Alfred North
Religion
Science and the modern world
Whitehead, Alfred North
Science
Accordingly, in criticising an argument based upon the application of
mathematics to particular matters of fact, there are always three
processes to be kept perfectly distinct in our minds. We must first scan
the purely mathematical reasoning to make sure that there are no mere
slips in it—no casual illogicalities due to mental failure. Any
mathematician knows from bitter experience that, in first elaborating a
train of reasoning, it is very easy to commit a slight error which yet
makes all the difference. But when a piece of mathematics has been
revised, and has been before the expert world for some time, the chance
of a casual error is almost negligible. The next process is to make
quite certain of all the abstract conditions which have been presupposed
to hold. This is the determination of the abstract premises from which
the mathematical reasoning proceeds. This is a matter of considerable
difficulty. In the past quite remarkable oversights have been made, and
have been accepted by generations of the greatest mathematicians. The
chief danger is that of oversight, namely, tacitly to introduce some
condition, which it is natural for us to presuppose, but which in fact
need not always be holding. There is another opposite oversight in this
connection which does not lead to error, but only to lack of
simplification. It is very easy to think that more postulated conditions
are required than is in fact the case. In other words, we may think that
some abstract postulate is necessary which is in fact capable of being
proved from the other postulates that we have already on hand. The only
effects of this excess of abstract postulates are to diminish our
aesthetic pleasure in the mathematical reasoning, and to give us more
trouble when we come to the third process of criticism.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account