Scientific American Supplement No. 822, October 3, 1891Various
Science
Scientific American Supplement No. 822, October 3, 1891
Various
Science -- Periodicals
A discussion, in a recent number of the _British Medical Journal_,[2]
on "The Claims and Limitations of Physical Education in Schools," has
many valuable hints which should be followed by educators in this
country. Dr. Carter, in the leading paper on this subject, makes the
pregnant remark: "If the hope is entertained of building up a science
of education, the medical profession must combine with the profession
of teaching, in order to direct investigation and to collect material
essential to generalization. Without such co-operation educational
workers must continue to flounder in the morasses of empiricism, and
be content to purchase relative safety at the cost of slow progress,
or no progress at all." In other words, an advisory medical board
should coexist with our board of public education, to try to hold in
check or prevent a further "cruelty in trying to be kind." Private
institutions of education recognize the importance of physical
training and development, and in such institutions the deterioration
of vision is in proportion less than in institutions where physical
training is not considered. In one school of over 200 middle class
girls, Dr. Carter found that, during a period of six years, no fewer
than ten per cent. of the total number of girls admitted during that
time have been compelled to take one or more terms' leave of absence,
and of the present number twenty-eight per cent. have medical
certificates exempting them from gymnastic exercise and 10.25 per
cent. of the total present number wear eye glasses of some kind or
other. From my own experience the same number of students in our
schools would show about the same percentage of visual defects. These
questions are of such growing importance that not only instructors,
but the medical fraternity, should not rest until these evils are
eradicated.
[Footnote 2: Nov. 1, 1890.]
Dr. J.W. Ballantyne, of Edinburgh, in a lecture[3] on diseases of
infancy and childhood, says: "The education of the young people of a
nation is to that nation a subject of vital importance." The same
writer quotes the startling statement made by Prof. Pfluger, that of
45,000 children examined in Germany more than one-half were suffering
from defective eyesight, while in some schools the proportion of the
short sighted was seventy or eighty per cent., and, crowning all, was
the Heidelberg Gymnasium, with 100 per cent. These figures, the result
of a careful examination, are simply startling, and almost make one
feel that it were better to return to the old Greek method of teaching
by word of mouth.
[Footnote 3: _Lancet_. Nov. 1, 1890.]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account