Shakespeare, William, 1564-1616 -- Stage history; Theater -- England
It has been said that the putting out of Gloucester's eyes is an artistic
mistake on Shakespeare's part. I hold that it is a necessary incident in
the play, and that the dramatist has shown the reason for it. Cordelia
has set foot in the country with her French soldiers, determined to regain
the kingdom for her father, and Gloucester, whom Cornwall regards as
belonging to his own faction, is conniving with Cordelia. Now had
Gloucester been a common soldier, Cornwall could have put him to death as
a traitor (Act III., Scene 7); but the offender being an earl, Cornwall
dare not do this, so he puts out the old man's eyes to prevent him reading
Cordelia's despatches. He is blinded, moreover, in sight of the audience,
that Cornwall may be seen receiving his death-wound. And even the fact
that Regan and Goneril were capable of acting so inhumanly towards
Gloucester makes Lear's plight more desperate, and therefore more
pathetic. Yet Shakespeare never makes his characters suffer without giving
them compensations, and the meeting and reconciliation between the blind
Gloucester and his son is one of the most touching incidents in the play.
That this reconciliation was omitted in representation suggests that the
ugly incident of putting out Gloucester's eyes was retained merely as a
piece of sensationalism, and, if so, it merits severe condemnation.
Shakespeare has often been blamed for being intolerant to democracy, and
this is in part a well-founded reproach, but it was a fault of the age and
not of the man. Still, in "King Lear" the dramatist abundantly proves his
sympathy with the hard lot of the poor. For this reason the play preaches
no pessimism. Lear, Gloucester, and Edgar are the happier for the troubles
they experience. Such hardships as they endure are brought upon
themselves by their own shortcomings; but these hardships are mitigated
by the gain to their moral natures of a fellow-sympathy for the sufferings
of those who have done no wrong, and by an appreciation of the injustice
done towards those whose miseries are created through the selfishness of
the rich. Lear, who has ruled a country as a despot for half a century,
discovers for the first time in his life that--
"Through tattered clothes small vices do appear; Robes and furred gowns
hide all."
Having exposed himself to feel what wretches feel, he knows, as he has
never known before, how the heart of a desolate father can crave for the
love of a gentle daughter. To prison he can cheerfully go with her,
"To pray and sing and tell old tales, and laugh at gilded butterflies,"
because now he is no longer himself in the wrong, but the one who is
wronged. And the blind Gloucester, also, is happy in his misery, because
for the first time he can say:
"Let the superfluous and lust-dieted man;--
that will not see
Because he does not feel, feel your power quickly;
So distribution should undo excess,
And each man have enough."
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account