Traumatic neuroses; War neuroses; World War, 1914-1918 -- Health aspects; World War, 1914-1918 -- Veterans -- Mental health
A sensible and intelligent man, once the cause of his trouble has
been made clear to him, may be competent to continue to cure himself,
or, in other words, to re-educate himself, and completely to conquer
the cause of his undoing. But the duller and stupider man may need a
daily demonstration and renewal of confidence before he begins to make
any progress. It is precisely analogous to the experience of every
teacher of a class of students; the brilliant man will seize hold of a
principle at once and learn to apply it without further help, whereas
the dull man needs repeated and concrete demonstrations before it sinks
into his understanding.
In dealing with soldiers, and this applies with especial force to the
regular army, the conditions in many of the cases differ considerably
from those of the civilians. Trifling forgetfulness in the civilian
would perhaps not be a serious cause of worry, but in the soldier,
inured by years of training to strict discipline, forgetfulness of
even trivial instructions, or any difficulty in understanding complex
orders, is likely to bring down upon his head condign punishment. Such
lapses are regarded by the soldier as extremely serious offences,
because years of training and discipline have inculcated this idea.
When as the result of shock such soldiers are afflicted by even slight
forgetfulness, they become worried by it much more than would the
civilian and exaggerate its importance until it becomes a real terror
to them. As the result of their training they may regard such phenomena
as altogether abnormal; and by a process of rationalising what to them
is a novel experience, they are apt to imagine that they are going mad.
Such patients often dream about incidents in their army life when they
had been forgetful and got into trouble; they become obsessed with the
haunting fear that they are likely to get into perpetual difficulties,
are worried by the thought that they are incompetent for the duties to
which they have been accustomed, and may imagine themselves debarred
from all useful work. However, they are easily reassured when the
medical attendant explains to them that in ordinary life civilians
are frequently subject to such experiences, and that it is only the
special circumstances of army life which make such trivial lapses seem
serious to them. Not only is the soldier much more scared by such
things than the civilian, but it is also a very remarkable phenomenon,
and certainly one which came as a surprise, that the neurasthenia of a
soldier is apt to be very much more serious than that of the civilian.
For when a really brave man is stricken by fear he is more seriously
affected by the terror of an experience which to him not only has a
larger element of novelty than in the case of the civilian, but also
wounds him more deeply by convincing him that he is lacking in that
very quality which is most essential for his professional work.
_The Therapeutic Value of Work._
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account