Traumatic neuroses; War neuroses; World War, 1914-1918 -- Health aspects; World War, 1914-1918 -- Veterans -- Mental health
We may take as a good example of the historical complexity of
significant attitudes and actions in life, the process of falling in
love—especially if it is not, or at least seems not to be, love at
first sight. It is generally admitted that, in the development of this
psychological phenomenon, onlookers see most of the game. In other
words, the actions of the two persons who are gradually becoming more
and more attracted to each other are partly determined by motives,
which, unknown to them, are patent to their observant relations and
friends.
Further examples may be given to illustrate this important and
oft-disputed point. Let us suppose that a musical critic, after
hearing a new symphony by an unconventional composer, immediately
writes a lengthy appreciation of the performance. It is clear that
nobody would expect him to be able to give, off-hand, an account of
his reasons for every sentence of the criticism. But it is obvious
that a single phrase in this account may be but the apex of a whole
pyramid of memories emanating from the critic’s technical training,
his attitude towards the new departure, experiences highly coloured
with emotion which a few notes of the music may have evoked, and his
mental condition at the time he heard the performance. Nobody denies
that these may have shaped or even determined his criticism. But who
believes either that they were all conscious at the time of writing
the article, or that he could resuscitate them without much time and
trouble and perhaps the help of a cross-examiner?
Again, there are occasions when society expects that a man shall be
unconscious of the reasons for some of his actions. He is expected, for
example, to behave politely, attentively and chivalrously to ladies,
not because at the moment of taking the outside of the pavement he
remembers why he does so, but simply because he has been brought up in
this way. And conversely, too conscious politeness in a man arouses in
others—and often rightly—the suspicion that it is a recent acquisition.
We see then that it is rare for a man to be able to give a true
account, even to himself, of the reasons underlying his important acts
and beliefs, when his mental condition is relatively calm and his
social relationships are normal. But when a case of mental disorder is
in question it becomes quite obvious that the patient is frequently
not in a position to give, either to himself or to another, anything
like a complete or true enumeration and description of the antecedent
experiences which have brought about his present condition.
It therefore becomes necessary to admit that unconscious factors of
great importance may play an influential part in the production of
mental disorder and that, therefore, some way must be found of tapping
these submerged streams.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account