Traumatic neuroses; War neuroses; World War, 1914-1918 -- Health aspects; World War, 1914-1918 -- Veterans -- Mental health
The task of psychological analysis is rendered difficult by the fact
that not all the motives of the patient’s present beliefs, attitudes
and actions are conscious; the entry into consciousness of some of
the unacceptable motives and memories is obstructed by various mental
processes. When the action of these shielding mechanisms has been
subverted by various means the real significance and history of the
patient’s present mental condition becomes clear to him. In the light
of this new self-knowledge he begins to cure himself. In a few cases he
may require little or no subsequent assistance, but usually a process
of re-education[46] is necessary. He may still require to be helped
over some of the obstacles which he meets, and he may need more or
less frequent encouragement and advice to an extent determined by his
disposition, temperament, and character. By these means he is “freed
from himself,” liberated from the exaggerated emotional tone which has
become attached to so many of his memories, and so enabled to face life
anew with a harmonious and integrated mind.
The procedure which we have discussed is precisely that which the
sensible mother adopts towards a child who exhibits sudden and
unreasonable fear, anger, or any socially undesirable emotion. The same
method is adopted towards the man who, having muddled his financial
affairs, appeals for advice to an experienced and judicious business
friend. “Firmness”—of the unsympathetic and unintelligent order—may
occasionally produce good results in both these instances, but usually
it only makes matters worse. Paying for the commercial muddler a few
of his chief debts may remove his embarrassment for the time, but if
unaccompanied by an attempt to reform his business methods, the result
will usually be merely that such a treatment will enable him to incur
fresh liabilities. So it is when a symptom or set of symptoms in a
neurosis is unintelligently removed: new troubles frequently break out
in fresh places.
We believe that there exist and can exist no serious arguments against
the procedure of psychological analysis and re-education which we have
just described. But now we come to speak of a procedure introduced
during the last few years which has certainly not escaped criticism
both of the most flattering and the most hostile kind. This is the
method of “psychoanalysis” which we owe to Professor Sigmund Freud, of
Vienna, who developed it as an extension and elaboration of the pioneer
work of his former master, Professor Pierre Janet[47], of Paris.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account