Traumatic neuroses; War neuroses; World War, 1914-1918 -- Health aspects; World War, 1914-1918 -- Veterans -- Mental health
Consequently there is no alternative but to apply to the Poor Law
authorities, who, under certain circumstances, provide treatment for
a period of two weeks in the workhouse infirmary. The whole system
is radically wrong. When the wife of an artisan becomes depressed
after confinement, surely it is cruel in the extreme to make her a
pauper and send her to the workhouse infirmary, pending a decision
as to whether she is insane or no. It is obvious in such a case that
this course will not be adopted until the last possible moment, and
consequently much valuable time is lost.
Every practitioner will be able to call to mind patients travelling
steadily towards insanity in unfavourable surroundings. This question
is brought even more prominently before consulting physicians,
especially those interested in nervous and mental diseases.” (_Op.
cit._, p. 42.)
In the words of the report of the Medico-Psychological Association:—
“The present system, which compels all persons, except those able
to pay adequately for their maintenance, to apply to the Poor Law
authorities in order to secure treatment, is unsatisfactory and
unjust. In doubtful and undeveloped cases temporary care can be given
only in workhouses or Poor Law infirmaries, which, with very few
exceptions, lack proper facilities for treatment.
_A system which artificially creates paupers in order to obtain
medical treatment necessarily acts as a deterrent, so that too
frequently there is serious and even disastrous delay._”[52]
This is not exactly locking the stable door after the horse has
gone; it is double-locking him thoroughly, expensively and often
unnecessarily, in someone else’s stable.
Let us, for a moment, compare this state of affairs with that existing
in the case of tuberculosis. Nobody now believes that the scientific
way of treating this disease consists in waiting until the patient has
become a positive danger to others, and then locking him up. This point
needs no elaboration. But another fact in this connection should not be
forgotten. The tubercular patient usually seeks the doctor _of his own
free will_, often obtaining treatment in a relatively early stage of
the disease.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account