Traumatic neuroses; War neuroses; World War, 1914-1918 -- Health aspects; World War, 1914-1918 -- Veterans -- Mental health
Other emotional states however, besides fear, arise and require
suppression. The tendency to feel sympathetic pain or distress at
harrowing sights and sounds, disgust or nausea at the happenings in
the trenches, the “jumpy” tension in face of unknown dangers such as
mines—all these, like fear, are or have been biologically useful under
natural conditions and, like it, are deeply and innately rooted in man.
But the unnatural conditions of modern warfare make it necessary that
they shall be held in check for extraordinarily long periods of time.
The impossibility of regarding modern methods of warfare in the same
light as natural and primitive means of fighting appears very clearly
when we consider the instinctive and emotional factors involved in the
two sets of circumstances. In natural fighting, face to face with his
antagonist, and armed only with his hands or with some primitive weapon
for close fighting, the uppermost instinct in a healthy man would
naturally be that of pugnacity, with its accompanying emotion of anger.
The effect of every blow would be visible, and the intense excitement
aroused in the relatively short contest would tend to obliterate the
action of other instincts such as that of flight, with its emotion of
fear. But in trench warfare the conditions are different. A man has
seldom a personal enemy whom he can see and upon whom he can observe
the effects of his attacks. His anger cannot be directed intensely
night and day against a trench full of unseen men in the same way
in which it can be provoked by an attack upon him by an individual.
And frequently the assaults made upon him nowadays are impersonal,
undiscriminating and unpredictable, as in the case of heavy shelling.
One natural way is forbidden him in which he might give vent to his
pent-up emotion, by rushing out and charging the enemy. He is thus
attacked from within and without. The noise of the bursting shells,
the premonitory sounds of approaching missiles during exciting periods
of waiting, and the sight of those injured in his vicinity whom he
cannot help, all assail him, while at the same time he may be fighting
desperately with himself. Finally, he may collapse when a shell bursts
near him, though he need not necessarily have been injured by actual
contact with particles of the bursting missile, earth thrown up by its
impact, or gases emanating from its explosion. He may or may not be
rendered unconscious at the time.[11] He is removed from the trenches
with loss of consciousness or in a dazed or delirious condition with
twitchings, tremblings or absence of muscular power.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account