In addition to the official documents on the subject of Spion Kop
much information of a very varied character has accumulated during
the last two years, and besides invaluable verbal observations and
descriptions gathered from conversation with officers from the front
who took part in the operations, there is a whole library of books by
newspaper correspondents, officers, and others, which bear upon these
operations and throw light upon much that is obscure in the official
papers. Among many others may be mentioned ‘My Diocese during the
War,’ by Bishop Baynes of Natal; ‘The Relief of Ladysmith,’ by Mr.
J. B. Atkins; ‘The Natal Campaign,’ by Mr. Bennet Burleigh; ‘London
to Ladysmith via Pretoria,’ by Mr. Winston Churchill, M.P.; ‘The
History of the War in South Africa,’ by Dr. Conan Doyle; ‘The Relief
of Ladysmith,’ by Captain Holmes Wilson; ‘Buller’s Campaign: With the
Natal Field Force of 1900,’ by Lieutenant E. Blake Knox, Royal Army
Medical Corps.
Magazine articles have also appeared from time to time, some
commenting on the operations themselves, others filling up gaps in
the narrative, and others again incidentally referring to facts in
connection with the operations. Among these last may be mentioned:
(1) A series of articles contributed by Sir Charles Warren himself to
the ‘National Review’ entitled ‘Some Lessons from the South African
War’; (2) Mr. Oppenheim’s defence of Lieut.-Colonel Thorneycroft in
the ‘Nineteenth Century’; (3) An instructive diary of Dr. Raymond
Maxwell, who was serving with the Boers, in the ‘Contemporary Review’
for December 1901; and (4) ‘The Diary of a Boer Officer,’ by another
of them, in the ‘United Service Magazine’ for February this year.
Some reference should perhaps be made to one of a series of articles
in ‘Blackwood’s Magazine’ by ‘Linesman,’ which was headed ‘Dies Iræ,’
and dealt with Spion Kop, because these articles have attracted a
good deal of attention, are cleverly written, and have since been
republished in book form. They do not, however, impress the military
reader as very accurate descriptions, but rather as war pictures,
in which the colour is laid on with no sparing hand to obtain
the highest effect, the aim being to please the sensation-loving
reader. The value of the account of Spion Kop given in ‘Blackwood’
is discounted by ‘Linesman’ himself, who, having told us that ‘what
the writer saw of the fight on the summit of Spion Kop was little
enough’; that he had learnt ‘to describe--nay, believe nothing that
one has not seen with one’s own eyes’; and that, ‘if the tongue is
an unruly member, much more so is the ear’; nevertheless proceeds to
describe in blood-curdling language what he did not see with his own
eyes, and must have heard with ‘unruly’ ears.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account