Alma-Tadema, Lawrence, 1836-1912 -- Criticism and interpretation
This is a truly marvellous picture, and it is not strange that Alma
Tadema retains it in his own hands. It is so true, so complex, so
alive, that at every view, with every changing light it reveals new
features, new aspects of sorrow, and yet with its profundity of
sorrow it is not too tragic to live with. It is so true, so human,
so beautiful, and so deep, that it does not repel. About Alma
Tadema's art there is nothing false or strained; he is always
healthy, there is in his nature no strain of morbidness, and hence
whatever he paints appeals direct to the truest feelings, whether he
paints the glad, sensuous world of the ancients, or the tragedies
which befell them, there is never in his work the sickly
introspection, the hyper-analysis of modern days. Just as in his
_Tarquinius and Emperor_, Alma Tadema proved that he could express
tragedy, so here he has shown conclusively that he can express pathos
and that he is possessed of a deep imagination, which, unfortunately,
he puts forth all too rarely. Had Alma Tadema created but this one
superb work he would be among the greatest artists of our time.
This _Death of the First-born_ is a true representation of Egyptian
life, and, as if to prove how accurate are the artist's instincts, it
is noteworthy that he placed at the feet of the dead a wreath of
flowers which strikingly resembles a like garland, found ten years
after the picture was painted, in the royal tombs of Deir el Bahari.
Meantime however, as we have said, he had begun to paint genre
pictures of Greek and Roman life, and so numerous are these, so
rapidly did he produce them, that it is impossible in our limited
space to enumerate even the most important. We have chosen a few at
random, taking care however to select from among the most noteworthy.
One of his finest early Roman pictures is, beyond question, the
_Tarquinius Superbus_, in which Tadema has shown what tragic power he
could wield when he wished. But his general inclination leads him to
let us see his men and women merely as they present their outward
faces. He cares not to look beyond, to apprehend the informing
intention, the psychic force of his creations.
This idiosyncrasy is based on the artist's character which is
singularly direct, and to which introspection and analytic research
is distasteful. Of quite a different character is the _Pyrrhic
Dance_, a wonderful _tour de force_. We are made to feel that these
Dorian fighters, executing a war-dance, are heavily armed, and that
it is only their skill and agility which makes their choregraphic
evolutions appear light under such heavily handicapped conditions.
Indeed, as we know from history, but few could execute with grace and
skill this "mimic warrior armour game" as Plato calls it, it might so
easily become ridiculous and it is not the least of Tadema's merits
in this canvas that he has treated it without the least touch of
exaggeration, and with a gravity and dignity that are truly admirable.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account