Sketches from the history of medicine, ancient and modern: An oration delivered before the Hunterian Society — John Shaqi
Sketches from the history of medicine, ancient and modern: An oration delivered before the Hunterian SocietySaunders, W. Sedgwick (William Sedgwick)
History
Sketches from the history of medicine, ancient and modern: An oration delivered before the Hunterian Society
Saunders, W. Sedgwick (William Sedgwick)
Medicine -- History; Speeches, addresses, etc., English
He, then, who ventured on the dissection of the human body, did so at
great personal risk, and for more than 600 years after the foundation of
Rome, no instance is known of the existence of any public professor of
anatomy. About that time Archagathus, a Greek, practised surgery in
Rome; and it appears that his use of the knife, and the actual cautery,
was so abhorrent to the general feeling, that he was saluted with the
opprobrious title of “Carnifex.” Even in later days the learned
Tertullian classed anatomists and butchers together in a philippic he
pronounced against Herophilus, whom he charged with having tried
experiments on the living body. He commences:—“Herophilus, the
physician, or butcher, whichever you please, who to become better
acquainted with men, ripped them up alive,” &c. &c.
Of this same Herophilus, who appears to have been a man of humour, as
well as genius, there is an excellent story told:—A certain _Diodorus_,
a contemporary philosopher and teacher of paradoxes, declared that there
was no such thing as _motion_. “If a body _moves_,” says he, “it moves
into the place where it _is_, _or_ into the place where it _is not_; now
it does not move into the place where it _is_, for what is _in_ a place
_remains_ there, and, consequently, one cannot say that _it moves_. It
also cannot move in a place where _it is not_; and therefore, it does
not move at all.” This acute gentleman having dislocated his arm, begged
the services of Herophilus, who, smiling, said:—“Either the bone of your
arm is moved into the place where it _was_, or into the place where it
_was not_; now it cannot move, according to your principles, either in
one place or another, consequently it is not displaced at all.” The poor
teacher of paradoxes saw that Herophilus was laughing at him, and in an
agony cried out:—“Leave, I pray you, _dialectics_ and _sophisms_ to me,
and treat me according to the laws of medicine.”
The inference that dissection was not openly allowed, will be
strengthened by a short reference to the subject of the embalmment of
the dead—the first mention of this custom is found in the 50th Chapter
of Genesis; where, at the second verse, we read:—That “Joseph commanded
his servants, the physicians, to embalm his father, and the physicians
embalmed Israel;” and at 26th verse of the same chapter it is
written:—“So Joseph died, being an hundred and ten years old, and they
embalmed him.”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account