Sketches of imposture, deception, and credulityDavenport, R. A. (Richard Alfred)
History
Sketches of imposture, deception, and credulity
Davenport, R. A. (Richard Alfred)
Common fallacies; Impostors and imposture
An image of our Saviour is shown at Rome, which, some time before
the sacking of that city, wept so heartily, that the good fathers of
the monastery were all employed in wiping its face with cotton; thus
following the example of the statue of Apollo, which, according to
Livy, wept for three days and nights successively. This phenomenon
resembles another, which is recorded respecting a statue of Orpheus,
in Libethra, which was made of cypress wood. When Alexander the Great
was on the point of setting out upon his expedition, various omens
occurred; among them, this statue was in a profuse sweat for several
days. Aristander, the soothsayer, gave a favourable interpretation to
this apparent indication of fear, by saying it was emblematic of the
labour the poets and historians would have to undergo, to celebrate
the actions of the Macedonian monarch.
Mrs. Piozzi mentions a ludicrous metamorphosis of one statue at Rome.
“A beautiful statue of Diana,” says she, “with her trussed up robes,
the crescent alone wanting, stands on the high altar to receive homage
in the character of St. Agnes, in a pretty church dedicated to her,
(fuor della porte) where it is supposed she suffered martyrdom, and
why? for not venerating that very goddess Diana, and for refusing to
walk in her processions at the new moons. ‘Such contradictions put one
from oneself,’ as Shakspeare saith.”
The incredible absurdities of some of the assertions made by the
possessors of sacred relics, ought to have been sufficient, in the
name of common sense, to convict them of imposture. What can be at
once more ridiculous and irreligious than the following? The monastery
of St. Benedict, in France, had for time immemorial been supposed to
possess that invaluable relic, the head of John the Baptist. Many years
since, however, the monastery of St. Francis overthrew their claim,
by declaring, that in their dormitory they had discovered the genuine
caput: and one of the friars testifying to its being the real head,
in the most solemn manner asserted that when, in a holy fervour, he
frequently kissed the lips, he found they still retained the flavour of
locusts and wild honey. So strong a proof there was no withstanding;
the claim of St. Francis was admitted, and established by the conclave.
The recital of one forgery only recalls another, and it would be easy
to recount well-authenticated tales, which would fill a volume. An
exhibiter of holy relics showed with much veneration the sword with
which Balaam smote the ass.[6] Being reminded that scripture only
recorded Balaam’s wish for such a weapon, he adroitly replied, “Ay, and
this is the sword he wished for.”
Those who have through motives of curiosity visited many of the shrines
abroad may have remarked an incredulity often lurking about the
countenances of the holy men who exhibit them: the bolder, indeed, will
openly laugh, when questioned as to their own belief on these subjects.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account