Social devices for impelling women to bear and rear childrenHollingworth, Leta Stetter
General
Social devices for impelling women to bear and rear children
Hollingworth, Leta Stetter
Child rearing; Fertility, Human; Public opinion; Social control; Women -- Social conditions
There is, to be sure, a strong and fervid insistence on the “maternal
instinct,” which is popularly supposed to characterize all women
equally, and to furnish them with an all-consuming desire for
parenthood, regardless of the personal pain, sacrifice, and disadvantage
involved. In the absence of all verifiable data, however, it is only
common-sense to guard against accepting as a fact of human nature a
doctrine which we might well expect to find in use as a means of social
control. Since we possess no scientific data at all on this phase of
human psychology, the most reasonable assumption is that if it were
possible to obtain a quantitative measurement of maternal instinct, we
should find this trait distributed among women, just as we have found
all other traits distributed which have yielded to quantitative
measurement. It is most reasonable to assume that we should obtain a
curve of distribution, varying from an extreme where individuals have a
zero or negative interest in caring for infants, through a mode where
there is a moderate amount of impulse to such duties, to an extreme
where the only vocational or personal interest lies in maternal
activities.
The facts, shorn of sentiment, then, are: (1) The bearing and rearing of
children is necessary for tribal or national existence and
aggrandizement. (2) The bearing and rearing of children is painful,
dangerous to life, and involves long years of exacting labor and
self-sacrifice. (3) There is no verifiable evidence to show that a
maternal instinct exists in women of such all-consuming strength and
fervor as to impel them voluntarily to seek the pain, danger, and
exacting labor involved in maintaining a high birth rate.
We should expect, therefore, that those in control of society would
invent and employ devices for impelling women to maintain a birth rate
sufficient to insure enough increase in the population to offset the
wastage of war and disease. It is the purpose of this paper to cite
specific illustrations to show just how the various social institutions
have been brought to bear on women to this end. Ross has classified the
means which society takes and has taken to secure order, and insure that
individuals will act in such a way as to promote the interests of the
group, _as those interests are conceived by those who form “the radiant
points of social control.”_ These means, according to the analysis of
Ross, are public opinion, law, belief, social suggestion, education,
custom, social religion, personal ideals (the type), art, personality,
enlightenment, illusion, and social valuation. Let us see how some of
these means have been applied in the control of women.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account