Social devices for impelling women to bear and rear childrenHollingworth, Leta Stetter
General
Social devices for impelling women to bear and rear children
Hollingworth, Leta Stetter
Child rearing; Fertility, Human; Public opinion; Social control; Women -- Social conditions
_Personal ideals (the type)._—The first means of control to which I wish
to call attention in the present connection is that which Ross calls
“personal ideals.” It is pointed out that “a developed society presents
itself as a system of unlike individuals, strenuously pursuing their
personal ends.” Now, for each person there is a “certain zone of
requirement,” and since “altruism is quite incompetent to hold each
unswervingly to the particular activities and forbearances belonging to
his place in the social system,” the development of such allegiance must
be—
effected by means of types or patterns, which society induces its
members to adopt as their guiding ideals.... To this end are
elaborated various patterns of conduct and of character, which may be
termed social types. These types may become in the course of time
personal ideals, each for that category of persons for which it is
intended.
For women, obviously enough, the first and most primitive “zone of
requirement” is and has been to produce and rear families large enough
to admit of national warfare being carried on, and of colonization.
Thus has been evolved the social type of the “womanly woman,” “the
normal woman,” the chief criterion of normality being a willingness to
engage enthusiastically in maternal and allied activities. All those
classes and professions which form “the radiant points of social
control” unite upon this criterion. Men of science announce it with calm
assurance (though failing to say on what kind or amount of scientific
data they base their remarks). For instance, McDougall[2] writes:
The highest stage is reached by those species in which each female
produces at birth but one or two young, and protects them so
efficiently that most of the young born reach maturity; the
maintenance of the species thus becomes in the main the work of the
parental instinct. In such species the protection and cherishing of
the young is the constant and all-absorbing occupation of the mother,
to which she devotes all her energies, and in the course of which she
will at any time undergo privation, pain, and death. The instinct
(maternal instinct) becomes more powerful than any other, and can
override any other, even fear itself.
Professor Jastrow[3] writes:
... _charm_ is the technique of the maiden, and _sacrifice_ the
passion of the mother. One set of feminine interests expresses more
distinctly the issues of courtship and attraction; the other of
qualities of motherhood and devotion.
The medical profession insistently proclaims desire for numerous
children as the criterion of normality for women, scornfully branding
those so ill-advised as to deny such desires as “abnormal.” As one
example among thousands of such attempts at social control let me quote
the following, which appeared in a New York newspaper on November 29,
1915:
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account