Social devices for impelling women to bear and rear childrenHollingworth, Leta Stetter
General
Social devices for impelling women to bear and rear children
Hollingworth, Leta Stetter
Child rearing; Fertility, Human; Public opinion; Social control; Women -- Social conditions
Only abnormal women want no babies. Trenchant criticism of modern life
was made by Dr. Max G. Schlapp, internationally known as a
neurologist. Dr. Schlapp addressed his remarks to the congregation of
the Park Avenue M.E. Church. He said, “The birth rate is falling off.
Rich people are the ones who have no children, and the poor have the
greatest number of offspring. Any woman who does not desire offspring
is abnormal. We have a large number, particularly among the women, who
do not want children. Our social society is becoming intensely
unstable.”
And this from the _New York Times_, September 5, 1915:
Normally woman lives through her children; man lives through his work.
Scores of such implicit attempts to determine and present the type or
norm meet us on every hand. This norm has the sanction of authority,
being announced by men of greatest prestige in the community. No one
wishes to be regarded by her fellow-creatures as “abnormal” or
“decayed.” The stream of suggestions playing from all points inevitably
has its influence, so that it is or was, until recently, well-nigh
impossible to find a married woman who would admit any conflicting
interests equal or paramount to the interest of caring for children.
There is a universal refusal to admit that the maternal instinct, like
every other trait of human nature, might be distributed according to the
probability curve.
_Public opinion._—Let us turn next to public opinion as a means of
control over women in relation to the birth rate. In speaking of public
opinion Ross says:
Haman is at the mercy of Mordecai. Rarely can one regard his deed as
fair when others find it foul, or count himself a hero when the world
deems him a wretch.... For the mass of men the blame and the praise of
the community are the very lords of life.
If we inquire now what are the organs or media of expression of public
opinion we shall see how it is brought to bear on women. The newspapers
are perhaps the chief agents, in modern times, in the formation of
public opinion, and their columns abound in interviews with the eminent,
deploring the decay of the population. Magazines print articles based on
statistics of depopulation, appealing to the patriotism of women. In the
year just passed fifty-five articles on the birth rate have chanced to
come to the notice of the present writer. Fifty-four were written by
men, including editors, statesmen, educators, ex-presidents, etc. Only
one was written by a woman. The following quotation is illustrative of
the trend of all of them:
M. Emil Reymond has made this melancholy announcement in the Senate:
“We are living in an age when women have pronounced upon themselves a
judgment that is dangerous in the highest degree to the development of
the population.... We have the right to do what we will with the life
that is in us, say they.”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account