United States -- History, Military; United States. Army -- History
If Lincoln were alive today, I fear he’d discover many lice on our
eyebrows--many fancies about our past that are contrary to reality. And
nowhere would he find more than in our mistaken notions of the Indian
struggles in our West. Soldiers fighting Indians! That’s what the
school histories lead us to see. We get the feeling that the soldier
was a bloodthirsty fellow who loved to go out before breakfast and kill
a few redmen for pastime. The truth of the matter is that he was the
best and almost the only friend the Indian had. The reason for this
relationship is natural and simple. The soldier had no personal gain to
get from the West. He wanted nothing that belonged to the redman. If he
were out for greed, as the settlers, traders, trappers and adventurers
too often were, he wouldn’t have been a soldier at his paltry wage.
And as a hardy fellow, he appreciated the good points in other hardy
fellows like the Indians. So let us look at real scenery and not at
lice for a few minutes. Here is the tale of the Modocs.
The Modocs had always been a peaceable tribe, often assisting the
whites in their undertakings, and even going so far as to help save a
California town from fire. The government had made a treaty with them.
As usual it violated it. All that these Indians asked was to be moved
to a small strip of land, no good to anybody. General Canby, known as
the Indian’s friend, tried to make the Indian Agents and Washington
see the point of view of these redmen and begged and entreated that
their simple request be granted. But the powers stubbornly refused.
The Indians, denied and double-crossed, went on the warpath. The
soldiers were ordered to fight them. In the ensuing engagements many
of them were killed. But that was not all. General Canby, Dr. Thomas
and other soldiers, in trying to carry out the government’s unjust
orders, were killed also. The very men who had tried to avert injustice
and bloodshed, were butchered. Dr. Thomas’ son has always claimed
that the government murdered his father. But the tragic irony of this
whole affair is that after all this debauch of human life and craze
of injustice, General Canby’s advice was finally heeded. Those that
were left of the Modocs, were transported to where they wanted to go
in the first place. But General Canby and many another good soldier
and Indian were dead. This story does not stand alone by any means.
That of the Nez Perce’s is even worse. This tribe was more peaceful,
high-minded and friendly than the Modocs. From the time that it had
helped the Lewis and Clark expedition, way back after our Revolution,
it had held uninterrupted good-will with the whites. But the government
defrauded these Indians of a little strip of poor land where they
wanted to go. They asked to be taken there. Chief Joseph, handsome,
intelligent, upright, patiently pleaded his cause. General Howard
naturally interceded and begged the government to let them go. But he
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account