Sources of the Synoptic GospelsPatton, Carl S. (Carl Safford)
Religion
Sources of the Synoptic Gospels
Patton, Carl S. (Carl Safford)
Bible. Gospels -- Criticism, interpretation, etc.
Luke's version seems more elaborated and less original than Matthew's.
Luke certainly would not have substituted the comparatively colorless word
διαμερισμόν for μάχαιραν if this latter had stood in his source. Without
the hypothesis of the two recensions this section would have to be
assigned to totally different, perhaps oral, sources. διαμερίζω is used
once by Mark, and Matthew and Luke have both copied it from him in that
connection. Neither Matthew nor Mark uses the word again; Luke uses it in
five other places in his Gospel, including the section now under
consideration. As he uses it but twice in Acts, it seems more likely to
have been found in his source than to have been here inserted by him. This
would tell strongly against the supposition that Matthew and Luke are here
working over an identical source; in other words, it would remove this
section from simple undifferentiated Q. Only the general character of the
material, its close resemblance in meaning in the two Gospels, and its
proximity in each Gospel to other Q material, can justify its assignment
to QMt and QLk--and then, even, with uncertainty.
CONDITIONS OF DISCIPLESHIP
(Mt x, 37-39; Lk xiv, 26-27; xvii, 33)
Luke's statement is much stronger, and so presumably older, than
Matthew's. Wellhausen says Matthew has been "refined out of Luke." In
Matthew, the two sayings about taking up the cross, and about finding and
losing one's life, follow each other; in Luke, at this place, they are
separated by more than three chapters. But both Matthew and Luke give both
of these sayings a second time, and the second time the two sayings are
continuous in both, as they also are in Mark, from whom they are taken.
The facts seem therefore to have been that Matthew and Luke each took both
of these sayings from two sources; that in Mark the two sayings occurred
together; that in Luke's recension of Q (at least), they were separated;
that they were probably separated in Matthew's Q also, but he has combined
them according to his habit, helped here by the recollection of the
continuity of the two sayings in Mark. The substitution of "who seeks to
find his soul" for the simpler form "who finds his soul" might easily be
ascribed to Luke; it is in the interest of logicality. But it is quite
unlike Luke to have added from oral tradition, or to have inserted from
any other written source, so much matter of his own as is found in his vs.
26. The section is therefore assigned to QMt and QLk.
"HE THAT RECEIVETH YOU"
(Mt x, 40; Lk x, 16)
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account