Special talents and defects : $b Their significance for educationHollingworth, Leta Stetter
Science
Special talents and defects : $b Their significance for education
Hollingworth, Leta Stetter
Educational psychology; Educational tests and measurements; Exceptional children
Other elements in musical sensitivity cannot be so readily measured in
stimulus units, so that the “times as” comparison cannot be made. The
great diversity of sensitivity to pitch may, perhaps, be regarded as a
token of the range of individual differences in musical sensitivity,
especially since pitch is a fundamental capacity. It is probably no
exaggeration to say that, in an ordinary class in the elementary school,
children are being taught together, some of whom are at least a hundred
times as musical as others. If children of the same age differed as much
from each other in height as they do in sense of pitch, it would be
impossible to teach them in unassorted groups, for some would be two
hundred times as tall as others. The diversity in mental traits, so much
greater than in physical traits, leaves us complacent, for the eye
cannot behold the incongruities, as it can in physical matters. The eye
cannot see the waste of time, effort, and joy which follows from the
attempt to train, equally and together, children of such widely
differing capacities for learning.
IX. CAN MUSICAL CAPACITY BE INCREASED BY EDUCATION?
Musical sensitivity is inborn, and probably cannot be increased in any
respect by training. If the various elements are not present in amount
and combination suitable for a given degree of achievement in music, no
course of training will supply the lack. This is not to say that
ultimate achievement, for those who do possess capacity, does not depend
on training. Achievement depends upon both training and capacity, but
the latter cannot be supplied except by hereditary endowment.
The question of improvement through education becomes especially
important in a case where the psychograph is excellent, but for one
element. Much depends, of course, upon what the inferior element is, and
the degree of the inferiority, as to whether the person will be able to
succeed in a given musical career.
Inferiorities that appear in capacity for musical _action_ are possibly
much more susceptible to improvement by training than are inferiorities
of _sensitivity_.
For example, there are persons whose psychographs show excellent musical
talent, except that they falter from the pitch in singing. The voice may
be excellent in range, quality, and volume, yet with a falter in control
which leads to “flatting” or “sharping.” This is a defect in musical
action, an inaccuracy of movement.
It has long been known that the control of movement is brought about not
only through the kinæsthetic sensations, but through aid from the other
special senses as well. Vision is a first rate aid to the acquisition of
motor control. It is a more efficient aid than hearing, because much
finer differences can be detected by vision. The problem, then, in an
endeavor to improve by training those who “flat” or “sharp,” is to
devise some method whereby visual aid may be administered to control.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account